Yes they are paying like I pay for my health insurance but still have taxes that pay for public health subsidies like Medicare and Medicaid. I can't take my portion of those taxes and offset my premium costs.
But the privates aren't providing satisfactory results either when you look at the performance of their voucher students, it's worse most of the time. But that doesn't get any publicity. Only the notion that publics are bad and privates are good when it's not accurate.
Taxes are designed to benefit the public, not private companies.
I will most certainly speak about capitalism because the EdChoice proponents can't seem to grasp that most of their schools would be closed without public funds because the public doesn't see the value. Especially here in Cincinnati, the market is way oversaturated with Catholic schools, vouchers are keeping the doors open instead of the market doing what it's supposed to do. Use the tax dollars for exactly what they are supposed to be used for.