Boardman was 153-121 in the years from 1984-2010 which probably coincided with their best talent and (some) of the best coaching or at least individual teams between Bohren, Pallante, and Ogilvie. And they were playing a brutal schedule. It also included a Garry Smith presided destruction of the football program which led to a stretch of 2-28 from 03-05. Which is what makes the current struggles more sad. When Boardman went 3-7 in the 90s or 2000s, it was against a loaded schedule of 5-6 D1 playoff teams. Not so much nowadays.
Irony is Boardman's best run was probably between 1997-2002 when they had stockpiles of talent. Does one of those 3 non Garry Smith coaches win a state title in that period? Garry Smith was notoriously a man carried by his staff. Go rewatch Boardman play Pickerington in the playoffs in 1999, and watch a 10th grade Evan Beard steamroll guys all night and the team being led by its backup quarterback still get outcoached in the second half!
But Boardman was playing 3-4 private schools a season in those days, Ignatius, Ed's, St Francis, let alone Mooney and Ursuline. The community has changed a lot. Those families which were raising kids in Boardman during that 30 year period are now in places like Canfield. Or sending their own kids to Ursuline (heck I'd do the same to be fair).
It's sad, but if Boardman probably put on a serious coaching search when the job came open in the Spring of 1997 after Pallante went to Fremont Ross rather than hire Jack Hay (who promptly resigned after just a few offseason weeks) and promote Garry Smith from within, they'd probably have played in another state title game. But the community held onto the ideal of pegging academics, athletics, and the arts equally when they really had the football program last, and viewed it no differently than winning a cross country or softball championship (nothing against those sports).
www.wfmj.com
