Lots of wild over-reactions, as usual, in Buckeyeland. "Fire everyone!" "Burn it all down!" "Stroud is awful!" Grow up you spoiled children.
I think that two things lost the game:
1) Defensively, the Bucks played a 4-2-5 all year, with 3 safeties. Played it very well, lots of zone, covered up the weak corners with safety help, and as a result only gave up one play over 60 yard in the first 11 games. Everyone ran to the ball and they mostly stopped the run also. Knowles changed it up for TTUN, focused on stopping the run, and left his corners in a lot of man coverage. It sort of worked in the first half, they smothered the run but got burned twice with the man coverage - DBs were just not good enough, and nobody seemed to know their assignments. In the second half whatever adjustments were made failed - I rarely recognized the defense they were in, but somehow there were never safeties around when #7 popped through a gap in the line. Just a disaster of a plan. If Knowles had stuck with the plan they had all year, the kids would know their assignments, and the game would have been very different.
2) Offensive plays calls were overly conservative. I think Day felt the pressure. Most obvious were the 4th downs when we were across midfield and he punted. CJ really wanted to go for that first one and we punted. That showed a lack of confidence in both the offense and the defense, and that sort of timid/nervous thinking bled down into the entire team. Everyone played nervous in the 2nd half.
I also have to say Michigan played really well. They had answers for what we tried to do, and they made no mistakes. Their DBs were better than I expected. Credit to their coaches and players.
Having said that, firing Day or Knowles would be foolish beyond belief, thankfully none of the childish OSU fans are in charge. There is a tremendous recruiting pipeline in place; hopefully both coaches learned from their mistakes Saturday, and I'd be willing to bet that OSU is right back in the conversation next year for the championship.
I'd also love to see a USC or TCU loss to let the Bucks sneak in at #4. I still think this team would be a scary draw for UGA or UM in the playoffs.