St. Ed's also barely beat Elder, but I digress. I think Elder was capable of good play this year; they were just really inconsistent. For what it's worth, Drew Pasteur has kept updating his power rankings through the playoffs, and he has Moeller, Lakota West, and Princeton as the #2-4 teams in D1 respectively behind St. Ed's. St. X is still #5. Final 16 teams remaining in D1 and Drew Pasteur ranks:
Region 1
Lakewood St. Edward (#1 in D1, #2 overall)
Medina (12, 21)
Cleveland Heights (13, 25)
Canton McKinley (20, 39)
Region 2
Olentangy (9, 17)
Olengtany Berlin (14, 27)
Dublin Coffman (26, 58)
Springfield (17, 31)
Region 3
Gahanna Lincoln (6, 10)
Pickerington North (11, 20)
Hilliard Bradley (18, 33)
Upper Arlington (16, 30)
Region 4
Moeller (2, 3)
Lakota West (3, 7)
Princeton (4, 8)
Mason (22, 48)
Drew Pasteur's lines are also Moeller over Mason by 27 and Lakota West over Princeton by 1, which seem very fair.