I will give Archbishop Hoban a shot (and will miss some guys, I'm sure):
2001-2019 (senior season noted. No current players listed)
Offense
QB: Tom Sitko '02 - Kent State
RB: Tyrell Sutton '04 - Northwestern (Finished as #1 All-Time Rusher in OHSAA history, currently 2nd)
RB: Todd Sibley '16 - Pitt (Top 10 All-Time Rusher in OHSAA history)
OL: Mario Mascio '03 - Kent State
OL: Ted Steiber '14 - Minnesota
OL: RJ Kelly '17 - Akron
OL: Sean Glaser '04 - Toledo
OL: Nolan Rumler '18 - Michigan
WR: Jake Tersigni '13 - Dayton
WR: Garrett Houser '17 - Robert Morris
TE: Caden Clark '19 - Alabama
PK: Grant Kersh '16
Defense
DL: Greg McMullen '11 - Nebraska
DL: Ryan Thompson '02 - Boston College
DL: LaTroy Lewis '11 - Tennessee
DL: Daeshon Martin '17 - Cincinnati
LB: Jake Beiting '01 - John Carroll
LB: Devin Hightower '19 - Michigan State
LB: Dan Dario '06 - Fairmont State
DB: Jonah Morris '15 - Indiana/Akron
DB: Deamonte Trayanum '19 - Arizona State
DB: Nate Bauer '17 - Toledo
DB: Matt Salopek '18 - Miami (OH)
P: Tom Sitko '02 - Kent State
Other former 2001-19 players that likely merit being on the list: (QB): Danny Clark, Dom Orsini (RB): Tyris Dickerson, Laymon Carter III (OL): Zac Hamlin, David Sutter (WR): Morris, Erin McGough, Nick Marino (TE): Brian Slack, Jimmy Martter, Brett Talcott (DL): Jabari Taylor, Jon Lloyd, Jake Kepler (LB): Matt Collins, Arison Sanders , Dane Kersh, (DB): Tyler Gilchrist, Wil Fleming, Daulson Fitzpatrick