You are treating all 3 AD's the same. The first 5 years of the first AD went well, until there was a falling out of friends, including the Mean Girls. The 2nd AD was just a bad hire and bad fit for our school that even left our friends at Euclid High perplexed on why we hired him without vetting him. Believe it or not, of all the coaches, Kwas probably had the best relationship with him. Everyone had a problem with AD#2 including parents and coaches. Just a square peg in a round hole. The current AD worked well with Kwas this year. It is unclear what his stance really was with the non renewal, if he was just the messenger or the main driver. At the moment, I am leaning toward the later.