I get it. Girard lost Clardy, Jones, Gump, and Malito. Those guys are irreplaceable.
They do have a lot back... put the other Malito at QB and run a spread zone read offense. Maddox runs hard and Rutherford is a good receiver. Move Delgarbino back to guard... he could probably even play center. Lloyd was good last year, before he got hurt. Defensively, they have Cook and Lloyd on the DL, Maddox and Delgarbino at LB, and Malito and Rutherford in the secondary. That's not a bad core to start with.
I do think that Girard will be in for a long year if they try to put Delgarbino out there at QB again. They could still win 4 or 5 games though, even with Delgarbino at QB. They'd just get hammered in the other 5 games. Whereas with Malito at QV, they'd have a shot at a couple upsets.
Niles loses Mays, Davis, McMillion, Vaskin, and at least 4/5 OL... McGinnis. That's just their offense. They haven't played good defense in almost a decade.
They do have Leonard back at QB. Sudzina is a good 3 way player. When he's healthy, Molnar is a good RB... but he missed like half the season last year. But that's about it on offense. I think they might have a little more back on defense... but that isn't saying much.
I suppose Niles could be alright... but I just don't see it. I think 5-5 would be overachieving... and I'm only expecting 3 or 4 wins.