It's difficult to say what's going on at OSU. There certainly have been an unusually high number of knuckleheads lately.... But some signs indicate it may just be alot of bad luck.
1. Jim O'Brien: Did anyone think this was a guy who would pay players? OSU got burned bad on this one. They purposely went out to find the cleanest coach they could find. Hard to blame Geiger.
2. Maurice Clarett: Everyone knew he had an ego... But his HS schoolwork was very much in order and he was recruited by EVERYONE. Another case of bad luck for the Buckeyes in my opinion.
3. Irrizarry: Another kid who seemingly had it together in HS.
4. Albert Dukes: How do you talk to a kid and come away saying "I bet he's going to rape a 12 year old"?
Some positives: OSU easily lead the Big 10 in Adademic All-conference players. Some may say it's b/c they took AIDS awareness and basket weaving... But if you go down the list and look at the backgrounds of the students and their majors, you will see they these are actual STUDENT athletes from good solid backgrounds. OSU had 22 Academic AA's. Michigan I believe had 9. Half of Michigan's AA's majored in General Studies or Phys Ed.
OSU has declined to offer several ELITE ohio and national prospects b/c of grade or character issues and these kids have been snapped up by rivals. Ray Williams never got an OSU offer. Javon Ringer waited for one that never came. Freddie Lennix's offer is contingent on him getting his scores up. They yanked Miles William's offer and he just got into (big) trouble up at MSU. They yanked Derek Morris' offer and he has been troublesome at NC State.
Basically what I'm saying, is that OSU has not sold their soul to the devil in the recruiting process. Their admissions standards for football players are higher than practically every Big 10 school except Northwestern.
And if you look at the number of Academic casualties in the Tressell era vs. the Cooper era there is no comparison.
Something working for and against Ohio State is the location. No other school in the country of Ohio State's caliber and popularity is located in such a major metropolitan area. You've got USC and those kids are starting to get some fame.... But LA is not a sports town. They never sell out their home games. All other Big 10 schools along with the Notre Dame's, Oklahoma's, etc are in isolated college towns. No other team in the country has a newspaper with a circulation of 200,000+ where the college team is the #1 sports story year round. That makes these kids major local celebrities on a much larger scale than most other schools.
Graduation rates are up, grades are up, and admissions standards are up, and Tressell is winning the big ones (Bowl games and Michigan). 14 players were drafted by NFL teams last year. If you compared the Wonderlic scores of the OSU players to some of their rivals, they stacked up VERY favorably.... Especially to Miami. Gamble was really the only one with an embarrassing score.
Do they have things to work on? ABSOLUTELY!!!! Do I think they've been the victims of some bad luck and oportunistic media? Absolutely.
For instance, Miami freshman Willie Williams who was the nation's #1 LB recruit last year, was admitted to Miami despite having an arrest record as long as his arm (13 arrests I believe). He was arrested on his UF recruiting trip. Just this week he wrecked "his" late model Chevy Tahoe with custom everything while driving down to their bowl game. Will ESPN do a feature on how an indigent college freshman can afford a $50,000 SUV, the $120 in gas each month, and the $150 insurance each month? I doubt it.
I hope Alex sticks it out with the Buckeyes and I hope they can get the Knuckleheads in line. If things continue to spiral, I wouldn't blame him for bailing.