You know if you were starting from scratch you could take the current IVC concept and just changes the schools a little bit and come up with a pretty balanced, fun league. Here's my idea for fantasy land...
IVC North - Fairless, Tuslaw, Tusky Valley, Sandy Valley, East Canton, Malvern
IVC South - Coshocton, River View, Ridgewood, Garaway, Newcomerstown, Buckeye Trail
Travel would be pretty good, every school above 150 students offers soccer while none of the school under 150 do. Would give you 5 league division games with 2 natural crossovers based on equal size for a 7 game league schedule.
Then for volleyball, basketball and baseball/softball add Hiland to the South and Strasburg to the North.
Your soccer league is Coshocton, River View, Tusky Valley, Sandy Valley, Fairless, Tuslaw and Hiland.