Steve Specht is the greatest coach in the history of football not named Saban or Belichick but sometimes he's just too smart.
He benched Herbstreit after a 3 and out to start the game before realizing he can run behind St. X's massive offensive line leading to a 7-0 advantage with Vollmer behind center. Then for some reason Specht decides to pull Vollmer and put Herbstreit back in the game with 2:39 to go in the first half, but X is unable to run out the clock. Elder gets the ball at their own 24 yard line with 0:36 seconds to go and is able to take a 10-7 lead at the half. Then with the game on the line late in the fourth, X returns to Herbstreit for the first time in the second half to move them into field goal position.
(St. Xavier didn't have a pass completion for first down until their final drive in regulation which began with 0:37.)