School districts exist to satisfy the needs of the taxpayers, period, and all activities intra or extra curriculars exist to satisfy the need of the taxpayers at large to educate their children, grandchildren.
you are playing word salad here. if the purpose for the school district to exist was not to satisfy the needs of the taxpayers, school districts could not put levies on the ballot for taxpayers approval or disapproval. Tax levies are collected whether or not an individual has a child in the school district, thus, the levy is legal and justified to educate the children of the district being to the greater good of the public at large. Otherwise it would be legal only to levy the tax on the citizen with a child attending the school in the school district.
athletics or more properly, physical education is seen to enhance the educational process. there is no inherent educational value to having a winning record, thus recruiting a student for athletic purposes only, is not justified as the additional student causes the school district to incur additional expenses which are not reimbursed by the State and the school district benefits no more by any athletic enterprise winning games than losing games and winning games is not the purpose to have an athletic program in high school interscholastic competitions because it is a zero sum game: for every winning team there is a losing team and the losing team must be gaining as much educational benefit as the winning team, or else the expensive activity cannot be justified, musical activities are not like this, with a winner and a loser: every child in every band gains approximately equal educational benefit. the same goes for debate or chess team or academic challenge or theater: while there is a winner and a loser theoretically in a debate, or chess tournament, or robotics competitions: the team that doesn't "win" learns as much as the winner in theory.
It's not about who wins: its about learning. if it's not about learning, it has no place in the education system. kid's parents can pay for their own recreational activities except for recreational activities provided to EVERY student. respectfully submitted