I know Paul Brown’s 1940 team was one of the best teams ever out of Massillon. They blew out Kent State in a scrimmage and if I’m correct that Kent State team finish the year with either 1 or no losses.
Another Tiger team the 1970 team was another team that I think is probably one of the best teams ever out of OH. That team possessed six players that either played in the NFL or were in NFL camps.
Mike Mauger - Ohio MVP Wisconsin/Kent State - Dallas Cowboys training camp
Dennis Franklin - Michigan - Detroit Lions
Steve Luke - Ohio State - Green Bay Packers and Atlanta Falcons
Tommy Hannon - Michigan State - Minnesota Vikings
Willie Spencer - No college - Hartford Knights, Memphis Southmen, Minnesota Vikings, New York Giants
Steve Studer- Bowling Green - Chicago Bears training camp
I don’t know of another team in Ohio that can claim that many professionals on one team.
Glenville had seven on their 2009 & 2010 squads...
'10 LB Jayrone Elliott- Green Bay Packers, Dallas Cowboys, Pittsburgh Steelers
'10 FS Christian Bryant- St. Louis Rams; Arizona Cardinals
'11 ATH Shane Wynn- Jacksonville Jaguars
'11 CB Justin Hardee- New Orleans Saints; current NY Jet
'11 DT Willie Henry- Baltimore Ravens; San Francisco 49ers
'11 QB Cardale Jones- Buffalo Bills
'12 LB Chris Worley- Cincinnati Bengals
'13 CB Marshon Lattimore- current New Orleans Saint
'13 DT Davon Coleman- Dallas Cowboys