Yappi Members Rank Moeller ahead of Elder??

[consumerman]

Why???


For Elder:

Elder is 7-3, Moeller also has 3 losses

Elder beat Moeller head to head

Or was it Elder DESTROYED Moeller head to head

In the Herbie, Moeller LOST to a 3-2-1 Cali team
In the Herbie, Elder BEAT a nationally ranked team with a 109 game win streak

For Moeller:

I guess that system that Ohio uses has Elder one seed better than Elder

To me it is hard to argue Moeller should be rated higher than Elder

 

[concha]

Moe beat LaSalle and St. Edward, both of whom beat Elder.

Moe also showed that they are capable of at least scoring a few points on St. X, whereas Elder was shut out (and if you can't score, you can't win).

Not so crazy.

 

[LastMin]

i am sure it was a coin flip that decided this

 

[consumerman]

i am sure it was a coin flip that decided this

To Me, the criteria would be

1) overall record
2) head to head mathcups
3) prominent other games


ELder has a better record (barely)

Elder beat Moeller by 16 and apparently led by a lot more

Elder's win over Independence easily outranks any other game Moeller had

Elder lost by 3 AT St Eds, Moeller won by 3 at Moeller vs St eds (almost a wash)

not enough for me to override the first three factors

 

[NorrisHopper30]

Moeller is ranked higher in the city poll
Moeller has more harbin points

I guess Moeller had a better season?

Polls don't matter anyways, it's all about getting to the playoffs and finishing strong.

 

[consumerman]

I guess I could question the same poll which has St Ig #5 with 2 losses and Mentor unranked with 2 losses

Mentor beat St Ig head to head by 21 points

?!?!?!?!?!

 

[Fightingfor7crusader]

I know this really does mean much, but it's fun to compare.

Elder vs. St. Xavier PF - 14 PA - 63 Average Score St. X - 31 Elder - 7
Moeller vs. St. Xavier PF -14 PA - 28 Average Score St. X -28 Moeller - 14

 

[consumerman]

I know this really does mean much, but it's fun to compare.

Elder vs. St. Xavier PF - 14 PA - 63 Average Score St. X - 31 Elder - 7
Moeller vs. St. Xavier PF -14 PA - 28 Average Score St. X -28 Moeller - 14

how many points did ELder score on Moeller in the first half this year?

was it like 42? more??