Frank Howard in place of O'Neil : 4x All Star , NL ROY, 2x AL HR leader , AL RBI leader (1970) 382 Home runs over 1,000 RBI's
Blaine Wilson / Gymnast : America's Only 5x US National Champ, Silver Medal Olympic's, Silver Medal World Championships , 1997 Big Ten Athlete of the Year ( Charles Woodson won the Heisman that year) , Nissen award winner, Ohio State and the National Gymnastic HOF, 6x National Champ , 10x All American, 3x Big Ten Gymnast of the Year, 11x Big Ten champ.
He's got to go on this list somewhere for Franklin County he did things like Jack did in his Sport that no one else did or has done. Personally i'd take off O'Neal, Redd and Cassady .
Jimmy Cleamons has more NBA Championship Rings also than anybody from Ohio not names Hondo Havlicek as a player and a coach which moves Redd even farther down my list.
Bill Willis : Football Cols. East The Jackie Robinson of Professional Football . So many on and off the field accomplishments to list. In every FB HOF you can imagine on the 1940's All NFL Decade Team. look up you'll see his number hanging in Ohio Stadium
Franklin County :
Jack
Blaine Wilson
Bill Willis
Chic Harley / Archie
4 of these individuals did things nobody else has ever done and Chic Harley should have his name on Ohio Stadium . Tough crowd but i'd take these 4/5 over just about any County in the State. And all legit born in Columbus.