Because they’re a boarding school, nearly their whole team is international and only there for a year (maybe two). Son’s team played them two years in a row. First year (Covid year), they had only local area kids and we blew them out. Second year, only one of the players from the year before was on the team, nearly all international kids, and we lost like 4-2. It happened to be their Senior Day and all but one of their seniors were walked out by their host family.
They often start out the season with a few losses, basically because it takes a few weeks for these kids to just learn each other’s names, let alone how to play together.
Western Reserve Academy is similar but because they also have post-grad (5th year seniors) players, they don’t qualify for the playoffs. In the past, I thought AOA was the same, but not in the last few years.