PAC Game of the Year - 2004 | Tuslaw (2-1, 0-0 PAC) at Manchester (2-0, 0-0 PAC) | Week 4 | September 17, 2004
This is the sixth in an ongoing series, highlighting the PAC Game of the Year in each season, from 1999 through 2023, which will lead up to the start of the 2024 high school football season. For a look back at prior summaries, click here for
1999,
2000,
2001,
2002 and
2003.
_____________________________________
When they rolled out the 2004 schedules, it's safe to say, nobody anticipated the PAC Game of the Year to be the conference opener at James R. France Stadium in Week 4. In fact, in looking at the game stories for September 17, 2004, the featured PAC game of the week that week was a battle of unbeatens. CVCA, coming off that 9-1 regular season campaign and first playoff appearance the prior year, picked up where they left off and took a 3-0 record on the road to Coventry. The Comets - winless the prior year - had opened the season with three straight convincing wins over Norton, Norwayne and Cloverleaf. And on this Friday night,
The Akron Beacon Journal dedicated a third of a page to this showdown on the opening night of conference play. The host Comets cruised to a surprisingly easy 31-14 victory behind four touchdowns from Joe Slabaugh to move to 4-0.
But while CVCA and Coventry got top billing on the third Friday in September of 2004, neither was a factor at the end of the season. The Royals fell back to 6-4 (2-4) to finish fifth in a 7-team PAC. Coventry posted a very good rebound season, but finished 3-3 down the stretch to wrap up the season 7-3 (3-3) and finish third in the standings.
So while most eyes were on the matchup at Coventry's Veterans Memorial Stadium, the true PAC Game of the Year was happening 4.9 miles south, just off Route 93. Of course it was at James R. France Stadium. And of course, it involved Manchester. The conference unbeaten streak was now at eight full seasons, and this time, it was Tuslaw who came into Manchester, with hopes of knocking off the Panthers.
Manchester opened the season with a 33-0 shutout of Mogadore. Week 2 saw the Panthers defeat something called the Columbus Crusaders in a game that did not count toward OHSAA playoff standings, and then the Panthers turned aside Smithville 42-28 in Week 3. The Tuslaw game was the fourth straight home game to start the season. Tuslaw had endured a trio of mediocre seasons by turn of the century Mustangs' standards (7-3 in 2000, 3-7 in 2001 and 6-4 in 2002). But this was a community that did not have to harken back too far to remember three straight 9-1 seasons from 1998-2000. And rest assured that no one had to remind the Mustangs that the "1" in each of those great years was ... Manchester.
There is no doubt that the Tuslaw had the 2004 PAC season opener circled on their calendar, after opening with three straight WCAL matchups (wins over Rittman and Chippewa sandwiched around a one-score defeat to Dalton.
What we do know about that Week 4 Friday night is field conditions - always fair in the best of times - had to be most challenging that night in New Franklin. Up the road at Coventry,
The Beacon Journal described the challenge that befell the players in Northeast Ohio on that early fall night. "With standing water serving as mini-pools along the home sideline, leftover from an all-day rain, players splish-spashed their way through the chilly evening."
Naturally, on a night like that, ground and pound should have been the order of the day. And for the most part it was. Manchester ran 40 times for 183 yards on the night, while the Mustangs slogged out 139 yards on the soggy Manchester turf on 28 rushing attempts of their own.
But it was the Panthers' Travis Gregory who opened the scoring in the first quarter, when he tossed a 17-yard touchdown pass to junior Phil Parton to put the hosts up 7-0. After a 3-yard run by junior fullback Greg Hooper in the second quarter, Manchester doubled its lead to 14-0.
But then the game took a turn. Tuslaw didn't fold. They didn't buckle. The Mustangs punched back. A 28-yard scoring run got the Mustangs on the board before the half. Tuslaw tied it on a 48-yard run by quarterback Brian Williams in the third quarter, and when Jeremy Triner found paydirt on a 10-yard touchdown run early in the fourth, the long Panthers conference win streak appeared to be in jeopardy.
Choose your own metaphor. There was still time on the clock. The last nail was not yet in the coffin. The Panthers' heart was still beating. And like Lucy and Charlie Brown with the football, this act had been seen before - just two years earlier in fact. Here's an excerpt from the 2002 Game of the Year Post:
What came next came deep from the Trickeration Bag of head coach Jim France. The 1981 Dolphins had Strock to Harris to Nathan in the famous Hook and Ladder play against the Chargers. Twenty years later, the Manchester Panthers drew up Swain to Calvert to Feesler. Perhaps Tusky Valley should have seen it coming. Manchester ran the same play a week before against Tuslaw. But they didn't. Josh Feesler crossed the goal line, and that stingy Panthers defense held.
Looking at a one-score deficit on a sloppy and chilly night, Koach dialed up
the same play. This time, the protagonists were quarterback Travis Gregory, receiver Keith Carrier and Josh Fagen. The three connected - again - on
The Hook and Ladder for a 33-yard scoring strike and Manchester drew even with 4:42 to play.
After the Panthers defense forced a punt, Parton rumbled 34 yards for the winning score. The conversion failed but Manchester tacked on a safety for the final margin. The Panthers streak continued. Tuslaw was foiled again. Final Score: Manchester 29 Tuslaw 21.
The Postscript
Tuslaw rebounded from the Manchester setback and reeled off six straight wins to finish the regular season at 8-2 (5-1) for their best showing in the PAC since 2000. The season ended in Week 11, when the Mustangs dropped a 28-6 decision as a 7-seed in the Division 4 Region 13 Regional Quarterfinal at Chagrin Falls.
Manchester was not as defensively dominant as in prior years. They had one-score games with Tusky Valley, CVCA and Fairless. But they won them all and were a perfect 9-0 heading into the postseason - again as the 1-seed in Division 4 Region 13. But history has a way of repeating itself, and the season ended in another Week 11 "upset" at the hands of Youngstown Ursuline, who again came to New Franklin - just as they had two years earlier - and left with a 21-3 victory. Manchester had no reason to hang their heads. It was another undefeated regular season and nine straight years without tasting defeat in a PAC contest.
A Bonus
Sometimes, when researching for these recaps, you find something that is just too good not to share. Tuslaw's Jeremy Triner got a brief mention in the story above, when his touchdown run gave the Mustangs a short-lived lead. Do yourself a favor and read about his homecoming from Afghanistan in 2011. The Mustangs may not have won on the field back in Week 4 of 2004, but we are all winners because of the bravery and service of Marines like this Mustangs Alum. Oorah!
_____________________________________
Here's a look back at the short game recap and box score from the ABJ on the Saturday following the game: