Friday Finals (11/17/23)

Wildcat97 said:
or one could say 3/4 are public, as usual, and the outcry is ridiculous when the vast # of titles are won by publics...
Click to expand...
So the concept of disproportionality is beyond your comprehension?

Wildcat97 said:
...except for your blind squirrel recruiting machine which will probably win 1 for the first time this year
Click to expand...
Ya gotta admit, the idea of an Ignatius fan accusing any other school of recruiting deserves a good chuckle.
 
Ohioriverboy42 said:
But not all regions have private schools in them. That's why Region 2 and 3 champions always are public schools. But how often do public schools win Regions 1 and 4??
Click to expand...

Ohioriverboy42 said:
D4 is wide open, D1 does get dominated by private schools over the last five -10 years
Click to expand...

Pubic schools D4 Champions
Glenville 2022
Massie 2021
Van Wert 2020
Clyde 2019
Wyoming 2018
Steubenville 2017
Bishop Hartley Private 2016
 
Considering this comes up so often I'd almost be fine with private/public separation so long as the public school division could NEVER say "well we would've beaten the private school division champ this year, we were that good".

Again, be careful what you wish for.
 
kmac57 said:
Pubic schools D4 Champions
Glenville 2022
Massie 2021
Van Wert 2020
Clyde 2019
Wyoming 2018
Steubenville 2017
Bishop Hartley Private 2016
Click to expand...
Glenville is a little different from alot of the other schools on the list. It's apart of a large urban district and doesn't have attendance boundaries (unless you do extracurriculars at Glenville and attend Ginn Academy, which would mean you'd have to live in the Glenville zone). Which is fine by me. I'm a Glenville fan. I don't care how kids matriculate there. As long as it's not against the rules
 
Ohioriverboy42 said:
But not all regions have private schools in them. That's why Region 2 and 3 champions always are public schools. But how often do public schools win Regions 1 and 4??
Click to expand...
Since 2008 (within the non-diaper lifetimes of today's players), with the usual asterisks for 2013/2014:

Region 4
2023 - Moeller
2022 - Moeller
2021 - Moeller
2020 - St Xavier
2019 - Elder
2018 - Colerain
2017 - Colerain
2016 - St Xavier
2015 - Colerain
2014 - Moeller < Wayne
2013 - Moeller > Hilliard Davidson
2012 - Moeller
2011 - St Xavier
2010 - Wayne > St Xavier
2009 - Elder
2008 - Elder
---
Moeller 6, St Xavier 3, Elder 3, Colerain 2, Wayne 1 (or 2), Hilliard Davidson (maybe 1)


Region 1
2023 - St Edward
2022 - St Edward
2021 - St Edward
2020 - Mentor
2019 - Mentor
2018 - St Edward
2017 - Mentor
2016 - St Ignatius
2015 - St Edward
2014 - St Edward > Hudson
2013 - St Edward > Mentor
2012 - Mentor
2011 - St Ignatius
2010 - St Edward
2009 - Glenville
2008 - St Ignatius
---
St Edward 8, St Ignatius 3, Mentor 5 (or 4), Glenville 1, Hudson (maybe 1)
 
eaglesfan216 said:
Considering this comes up so often I'd almost be fine with private/public separation so long as the public school division could NEVER say "well we would've beaten the private school division champ this year, we were that good".

Again, be careful what you wish for.
Click to expand...
You think anyone would care about that? It would be more fun listening to Hoban whine because they couldn’t beat Ed’s in the private regional final……and Iggy and TCC. The same 3 to 4 teams over and over in the final. Boring. The private state champ game would turn into Hoban traveling to St. Francis……86 people in the stands and no one cares. Be careful what you wish for.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top