Ohio is well represented. Obviously it skews toward players who played next level and beyond but I thought all the Ohio teams on the list deserve it. That '93 Ignatius team blew everyone out with a tough schedule (except Ed's in a classic 35-34 3OT game). Moeller's first state title was the year before, espn gets that wrong (beat Ed's 14-12, another classic). '97 McKinley was an incredible team and their two games with Ignatius in the playoffs were something special when you think about '98 too. The 1927 Waco team played Cleveland Cathedral Latin. In "When the Lions Roared" about the Cathedral Latin football program, the author says Waco had a cutting edge passing offense that no one in Cleveland had ever seen. It didn't help that they had been practicing inside a gym for a month before taking the train to Waco. The Massillon teams under Paul Brown speak for themselves.
I think the saddest parts of these things is that there is not room for everyone. The points made about '04 Colerain and '07 St. Xavier are well taken. I'd add 2010 Ed's to that list too. Small schools get screwed as well. I get that its about the talent but there are some phenomenal small school teams that have had amazing runs of dominance.