Walnut Hills is D2. Other possibilities include Luers from Moeller, Hoffmeyer/Daeschner from Elder, Roberts from X.
Walnut Hills is D1
Good catch, my mistake. I was going off here where they're listed as D2: http://www.ohioboysvolleyball.com/index.php/team-schedules
Could they be placed in D2 based on being a new program?
Unfortunately the team result often helps a player reach 1st or 2nd Team status. Look no further than Wernery last year winning POY over Clarke. Though to say that Witte isn't deserving of 2nd Team is comical.
Based on where they play for their respective H.S. teams...
Every regional POY will be 1st team all state. So Holzheimer and Mikesch are almost certainly locks. Pung, Klusman, and Bowles are also locks IMO as they are the pretty clear standouts on their teams. Then you have two spots out of the East region for Darby and WS' top players. Moldovan/Brinkerhoff and Woodson/Szwabinsky.
Is this you picking the best players to play in a match or picking your All State Team? They probably shouldn't be, but the two are different.
Although this would be a solid list too:
S- Holzheimer? I haven't seen him play, but looking at this thread I'm going to assume he can ball.
OH1- Woodson. Go to guy for Westerville who has taken down Moeller, Iggy, & Beavercreek.
OH2- Bowles. He's their go to guy in or out of system who took down Elder & X.
MH1- Carpenter. One of the top 5 middles in the state.
MH2- Witte. Ditto ^
RS- Miller. He may be the most underrated RS in the state. Besides Klusman who else is there to talk about??
L- Huber. I could see him getting a few offers next year. He could be elite if he was 6'' taller.