MCGal - that is not how All-Ohio teams are voted..
For All-Ohio, coaches who are part of the OHSFSCA (Ohio High Fastpitch SoftbalL Coaches Association) nominate players for All-Ohio and then coaches from that district vote. Coaches don't vote for players not in their district. That is basically how the process goes...
What school is she from? It is highly likely that her schools coach is not a participating member in the coaches association therefore cannot nominate or vote on players.