A couple of stories...
The Redmen were pasting Springfield in first round of 1991 playoffs at Donnell. Damon Moore was a freshman and came in as the back up QB to spell Kidwell. He was electric and ran roughshod over Springfield's first teamers in the second half. Nordonia's coaches were there as they added Fostoria to the schedule the following year. When they saw Moore, as a freshman, knowing they would have to face him the next two years, the next day Fostoria got a call from them to cancel the contract.
In the early 1990s, soccer goals were constructed in the fields adjacent to the high school. After the coaching staff was alerted, they were removed the next day.
I can remember in 1991 going downtown with everyone else to greet the Redmen on their return home from winning a state title. There were thousands of folks jammed into the downtown area at midnight as the bus pulled in and they were pounding on the bus whooping it up. It was an amazing scene.
I played across town during the 80s when the Redmen were very good. I'd bet you couldn't find a town in Ohio of the same size that had the level of HS football talent that Fostoria had between FHS and St. Wendy in the 1980s and early 1990s. Both teams in town went 10-0 in 1983 and the Boosters brought an aging Woody Hayes in to talk to both teams.