Massillon's win against Ignatius is legit. The Tigers earned it. I also don't blame Massillon for not scheduling Ignatius anymore. They played what, 12 or 13 times? That's more than more local teams.
Kudos to Mentor for their willingness to play a very tough non conference schedule.
Massillon had 10 regular season games with Ignatius. 6 of the 10 were very competitive games (including the last one). 4 were, well, not.
There aren't a lot of 10 year series out there between any two teams that are competitive games in all 10.
Mind you I'm not anyone who was involved in the series ending, but I'm assuming Ignatius was probably willing to keep it, but wasn't really pushing the issue when the decision was made to end it at 10 games.
I know Hall was part of the group of coaches/admin who decided to not play the big private schools for a while. He openly said it. So I'm sure he honored the deal, and moved on.
Beyond that, the series really never was able to keep its initial luster. Attendance numbers back that up (as pointed out, the last game at PBTS drew less fans than Buchtel did at PBTS).
Fast forward to now, and picking this series back up doesn't make sense. When this series first started you had two d1 teams that had a good chance of meeting in the state semifinals (which happened in 2001, and Massillon was there in 2002 but Ignatius lost to Warren week 11, who Massillon played in the semis; again in 2007 Massillon played the team Ignatius was knocked out by. 2008 the opposite happened.)
However now, we don't have that. Massillon is solidly in D2 and Ignatius D1. The whole intrigue around a regular season preview of what had a good chance of being a state semi matchup is gone.
Two programs in different situations. Ignatius is in the home stretch of Kyle's career and Massillon is in transition with a completely new coach with a completely different philosophy.
Right now I'm not sure if you put a mutual open date with an opportunity to renew the series in front of them that either coach would be jumping up to say "get it done"
Who knows.
-----
As for Mentor and Massillon. Nice to see it work out. This was a series that neither side really wanted to end, but league commitments and lack of mutual opens put the series on hold.
That series really never got boring. Both fan bases seemed to enjoy it and the kids got pumped up for it.
Enter Keith Wakefield pulling the "take my ball and go home" routine for the third time at perry since not getting the job he wanted at Massillon and viola! Mutual open date and both schools jumped on the opportunity. (Honestly, it's been 2 weeks since Keith took his AARP card off the table and Mentor and Massillon got the contract done.
Bravo.