2021 Steubenville Big Red

Win Total?


  • Total voters
    47

330740

Active member
Prior to 1972, when the playoffs started, polls determined the state champions. That was the system at the time. They should all count.
Has Massillon won any AP titles in the Playoff era and if so are they counted because this could determine if everyone is arguing the same point. If Massillon doesn’t count playoff era AP titles their pre-playoff ones have to the same worth as on-field titles
 

Maxie

Well-known member
Has Massillon won any AP titles in the Playoff era and if so are they counted because this could determine if everyone is arguing the same point. If Massillon doesn’t count playoff era AP titles their pre-playoff ones have to the same worth as on-field titles
The Tigers won the AP Poll in 1972 and 2019. We don’t count them as part of the 24 titles.
 

Foster

Active member
All championships should count. I was at Harding Stadium in 1962 when 8-0 Toledo Central came to play 8-0 Big Red. I believe they were ranked #1 and #2 at the time with Big Red being #1. Everyone in that stadium thought this was a championship game. TC won the game and the state title. The AP poll was the system at the time and our best barometer of the state teams.
 

Maxie

Well-known member
But additionally can you guys please win one for the paper tigers moniker to go away? How do u guys look coming back
👍 As you know, the Tigers have played in 3 consecutive playoff state title games. We are getting closer. The Tigers should contend again in 2021.
 

DB135

Well-known member
Anyone familar with the "poll era" KNOWS that those titles reflected on the field performance. Any contenders to the title scheduled each other the following season,validating those titles.

The "haters" would have you believe that "Massillon only" played in a bubble, of a weak conference and scheduled no independent contenders (their schedules, in fact illustrates the opposite).

This was the case where college poll champions upgraded their independent schedule to meet all contenders, to their poll titles.

Like I posted before, check (massillontigers.com) and post the teams Massillon ducked, that were legitmate challengers to their poll titles.

Just as equally uninformed, in an attempt to smear Massillon's tradition, if WHEN they do win a playoff title, it will not answer the haters trolling if it isn't in D1. That ALSO has been proven inaccurate as the top 5 teams in DII have proven in games against the top teams in D1. Many years the top team in DII is "THE BEST TEAM REGARLESS OF DIVISION", in the state!

If you don't try to invalidate Massillon tradition, NO team has even an outside chance of equaling it, THAT is the real reason "SOME" posters live to troll. (Hate not legitimate, fact based arguments)!

True Massillon fans aren't as they are characterized by the trolls on this board. We accept and understand the truth abour our program be it good or bad. Titles of either era have challenges to their legitimacy. Massillon always played the best and that resulted in an unequalled tradition.

That includes decisions that enable the program to compete for a state title on an equal playing field, illustrated by their current performance.
 
Last edited:

TCSoup

Well-known member
Agree, i have no dog in the fight.

A great read is Tim Raab's Book Powerhouse's Of Ohio High School Football The 50's and 60's He did thorough Fact and Background checks in every aspect of his book. Digging through as many Newspapers and School archives as possible. Conducted countless interviews with AD'S and Coaches, Newspaper Reporters and Librarians to get as much information about Years, Seasons, Roster's , and Schedules , Results.

One thing you will find is even with no internet or cable TV HS Coaches were very aware of what the other Power houses across the State were doing every Weekend. They would with out a doubt play as many OOC Power Houses as their league schedules would allow. Based on current history and recent season results. Heck with One School Towns almost every area of Ohio had several Teams that were more than worthy opponents with out going out of your area. But you will see by many of the Schools Schedules there wasn't a lot of ducking of anyone going on.

Urge any HS Football Fan to pick up a copy. The Names of the Coaches and Players alone are a Who's Who of Ohio HS Football Legends.
 
.
Top