Underwhelmed, speaking for myself. They had a pulse, and I'm glad they were able to make the playoffs for the first time since 2016 (yeah, that's right) and play in their first playoff game since 2007. They should never have lost to Sycamore or Mason. There were three components of their season that I thought held them back:
-The mismanagement of the quarterback position. They tried to force a square peg in a round hole for seven games by starting MJ Horton instead of Dorian Durham. Horton is a great athlete and needed to have the ball in his hands, but not as a quarterback. They made the move late in the season and the offense moved a little better, but maybe Durham gets in a better rhythm late if he was the starter from the onset and maybe play Horton at receiver.
-Anything involving a long snapper. Nearly every missed kick this year was due to a bad snap. Snaps on punts were airmailed and I'm surprised more were not blocked. A bad snap on a punt directly led to them losing to Sycamore. I would like to see them have dedicated specialists at kicker, snapper, and punter (they did for kicker).
-Penalties. Far too many, again. They had about 1,000 penalty yards for the second year in a row. Many of them were personal foul variety. I'd be interested to see how many late hits out of bounds they suffered.
They won six games and I'd say five of them were due to vastly out-talenting the opposition. They played extremely well against West - that was a pleasing performance any way you slice it. Better discipline and play-calling would have allowed them to beat Mason and Sycamore and appear more dominant in the other games.
The cupboard is not bare for next year. I think they have just enough along the lines returning to be sound there. Some underclassmen emerged as well. The safety, Bowers, is a playmaker and was rewarded with a UC offer midseason. If Boyd can get in better shape at running back, he will play his way into an FBS scholarship. They have a budding #1 receiver in sophomore Rodney Harris. In addition to the above shortcomings, they need to groom a quarterback to do quarterback things, and not just stick an athlete in the backfield and hope he makes some magic.