It's been a number of factors.
- Dempsey is a good coach that has had success. Success begets success. St. Francis has had coaching instability since Cromwell left.
- Ed Choice has allowed kids to have mobility to go wherever they want. Kids have seen the success that Central has had in winning games and sending kinds to play at the next level (12 seniors off the 2023 team alone).
- Fewer kids are playing football.
- The kids that were team fillers, like I was, aren't as likely to play football anymore. That means a lack of depth across leagues. The good players on a team with no depth will likely depart to a better program where there are other good players.
- Kids have so many more choices nowadays. Kids that used to play football may now be playing lacrosse, soccer, or, unfortunately, video games.
- CYO football in Toledo is no more. The feeder programs for the Catholic high schools have had to be replaced. Both SJJ and SFS have Junior Academy teams, but they've had to reinvent how they get kids. Central started getting kids from the Stars League and the Mid City League 10+ years ago.
- Metro Toledo's population has been stagnant. The City of Toledo's population has declined from 383,000 in 1970 to 270,000 in 2020. However, the metro population has remained static from 644,000 in 1970 to 643,000 in 2020. The population hasn't really declined. Instead it has moved to the suburbs and outer areas. Many CCHS, SJJ, and SFS alums now live in Anthony Wayne or Perrysburg districts and send their kids there.
I'm sure there are some other reasons, but these 5 are a big part of the rise of Central, the rise of Anthony Wayne and Perrysburg, the stagnation of SJJ and SFS, and the severe decline of the City League.