Not sure what the tuition comparison is at SFS and SJJ to Central but I did see Central's tuition is $10k a year. Now I did see they offer multiple forms of financial aid but still when its all said and done is it worth it to spend maybe $5k a year when you're already carrying the double burden of paying taxes and could send your kid to Perrysburg, Northview, Southview, Clay, etc...
Lima Central Catholic like almost every school in Allen County has seen their enrollments nose dive over the last couple decades but they've also seen some families (not necessarily the loyal LCC last names) make a financial decision to just go to Shawnee or Elida and save the $$$$.
I wonder how many of the SFS / SJJ alums go off to college and never return to the Toledo area. That's also something to consider in discussing future generations of those families not attending.