• Happy 24th Birthday to Yappi.com!! Just made it with a minute left before the Birthday was over!! Link

Who should get MVP

With all three quarterbacks having an exceptional year, who should win MVP?

  • Total voters
    28
  • Poll closed .
It's Manning only because Belichick > Caldwell. The Pats wouldn't be very good without Brady, but I think they would win a lot more than the Colts did.
 
Trains said:
It's a team game, not a one player team. If one player causes a complete collapse of a team when you team is stocked with some all-pro players on the roster such as Indy has, then it falls on the coach. Coach Bill in New England would not have a complete collapse like Indy has had this season.
Click to expand...

And what all-pro's did Indy have? Did you watch any football this year? MVP which is what this thread is about is an individual award not a team game award and not having Peyton Manning this season caused the whole organization to collapse from Poliani(GM) to Caldwell.
Furthermore NE would win 1 to 3 games w/o Brady this year. You must not of watched any football this year.
 
Zezzo! said:
And what all-pro's did Indy have? Did you watch any football this year? MVP which is what this thread is about is an individual award not a team game award and not having Peyton Manning this season caused the whole organization to collapse from Poliani(GM) to Caldwell.
Furthermore NE would win 1 to 3 games w/o Brady this year..
Click to expand...
And how, pray tell, do youi know that?
 
I can't believe people are being serious about Peyton Manning being MVP when he hasn't even played this season. I thought it was a big joke at first, but after I seen multiple people post it, I HAD to comment. Everyone who says Peyton should get the MVP award, should never post in the NFL forum again. Flat out. You CAN'T be that air-headed. Are you guys serious?! :eek: :Ohno:

So ridiculous that it's comical. :laugh:
 
Zezzo! said:
I'm going to throw this out there....I honestly think Peyton Manning deserves to be MVP. I've never seen 1 player be so valuable to a team. Tom Brady is as valuable, if he's out NE has the 1st pick in the following draft just like Indy.
Click to expand...

One of the dumbest posts I've ever laughed at, in Yappi history. How could someone be the 2011 MVP when he hasn't even played?

Giving someone the MVP award for what he HASN'T done, would be the dumbest decision in all level of sports' (male or female) history.
 
bearcatfan said:
He did it for a bazillion straight years. If he does it again next year, then you have to retroactively give Peyton the 2011 MVP award. If they suck again next year with him, then you have a case against him.
Click to expand...

So you should give him the award THIS year because he's done so great in PAST years? :laugh:

Keep 'em coming my friend! This is getting GRRREAT! I might have to print all this out and show it to some of my friends. :laugh:
 
bearcatfan said:
Which of these players is most valuable to their team?

Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Peyton

I don't see how you can't answer Peyton. Hence, he is the most valuable player out of those guys.
Click to expand...

You're right, if we were talking about past MVP awards. This is "who was most valuable on the field with their team in TWO THOUSAND AND ELEVEN".

So you think Peyton was more valuable to the 2011 Colts than Rodgers was to his 2011 Packers? ROFLMFAO if so.
 
Eezy as 123 said:
You're right, if we were talking about past MVP awards. This is "who was most valuable on the field with their team in TWO THOUSAND AND ELEVEN".

So you think Peyton was more valuable to the 2011 Colts than Rodgers was to his 2011 Packers? ROFLMFAO if so.
Click to expand...

Yes I do. Realistically I know Peyton can't win and I knew I would get negative feedback I'm cool with that however in saying that it shows how valuable one guy is to his team. It's hard for anybody to win in Green Bay regardless who the quarterback is (Flynn).
New Orleans has a great offensive scheme ran by a great QB but Brees does not have the impact that Manning or Brady has.

By the way Doug Gottlieb said the same thing on his radio show on ESPN radio so I guess he needs to have his show cancelled and stop analyzing.
 
If Brady does not put up 30+ points a game then his team probably only has 2 0r 3 wins.

No other team in the league has wide recievers playing DB in the NFL because all of the starters got hurt.

His defense is second to last place in total yards allowed. Green Bay is last, but Green Bay's defense is first in turnovers.

Brady makes his teammates into pro-bowlers. Nobody knew who Wes Welker was before he came to New England. Nobody thought Gronkowski or Hernandez would blow up, and they did so because of Brady.

It is the Colts fault for not having a back up in place to run the offense in case he got hurt, which is something New England did when Brady got hurt.
 
AllStateKnight said:
If Brady does not put up 30+ points a game then his team probably only has 2 0r 3 wins.

No other team in the league has wide recievers playing DB in the NFL because all of the starters got hurt.

His defense is second to last place in total yards allowed. Green Bay is last, but Green Bay's defense is first in turnovers.

Brady makes his teammates into pro-bowlers. Nobody knew who Wes Welker was before he came to New England. Nobody thought Gronkowski or Hernandez would blow up, and they did so because of Brady.

It is the Colts fault for not having a back up in place to run the offense in case he got hurt, which is something New England did when Brady got hurt.
Click to expand...

That's a lie.

The last time Brady was hurt for the whole season, the Pats started a qb who hadn't seen play time since high school and they won 11 games. Mallet is way better than Cassell.
 
Code: 
[B]2008 Patriots - 11-5[/B]   [b]2011 Patriots - 13-3[/b]
[U]Passing[/U]                [u]Passing[/u]
APG: 33.4 (12th)       APG: 38.2 (3rd)
YPG: 223.1 (12th)      YPG: 317.8 (2nd)
TDs: 21 (13th)         TDs: 39 (4th)
INT: 11 (7th)          INT: 12 (T-5th)
 
[U]Rushing[/U]                [U]Rushing[/U]
APG: 32.1 (4th)        APG: 27.4 (17th)
YPG: 142.4 (6th)       YPG: 110.2 (20th)
TDs: 20 (4th)          TDs: 18 (T-3rd)

[U]Defense[/U]                [u]Defense[/u]
RYG: 107.6 (15th)      RYG: 117.1 (17th)
RTD: 8 (T-4th)         RTD: 13 (19th)
PYG: 201.4 (11th)      PYG: 293.9 (31st)
PTD: 27 (31st)         PTD: 26 (T-22nd)
INT: 14 (T-15th)       INT: 31 (2nd)
FR: 9 (20th)           FR: 11 (T-7th)
 
aaron-rodgers-19th-espy-awards-1sctXb.jpg
 
Rodgers statistically had the best season a QB has ever had. If he had played the last game (assuming he puts up similar numbers to Flynn) he ends up with 50 TDs and 6 picks. That is ridiculous
 
Zezzo! said:
Yes I do. Realistically I know Peyton can't win and I knew I would get negative feedback I'm cool with that however in saying that it shows how valuable one guy is to his team. It's hard for anybody to win in Green Bay regardless who the quarterback is (Flynn).
New Orleans has a great offensive scheme ran by a great QB but Brees does not have the impact that Manning or Brady has.

By the way Doug Gottlieb said the same thing on his radio show on ESPN radio so I guess he needs to have his show cancelled and stop analyzing.
Click to expand...
No, he should keep his show and have you on it. The idiocy would be priceless.
 
Michael Bluth said:
Rodgers statistically had the best season a QB has ever had. If he had played the last game (assuming he puts up similar numbers to Flynn) he ends up with 50 TDs and 6 picks. That is ridiculous
Click to expand...

But we're not playing the "what if he played game". Ask Monte, Eazy, etc.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top