No, it was more an exercise in deductive reasoning that I emulated from your post above. As to your response to questioning military authority while being in the military and as you well know:
The military operates on a strict hierarchical structure, where each level of command has clearly defined roles and responsibilities. This system ensures that orders are carried out quickly and without hesitation, which is crucial in high-pressure, life-or-death situations. Questioning orders could lead to confusion, delays, or breakdowns in coordination, undermining the efficiency and effectiveness of military operations Unity and Cohesion. Military units rely heavily on cohesion and trust among members. When soldiers follow orders without questioning them, it reinforces a sense of unity and teamwork. This shared focus is vital for maintaining morale and executing complex missions. If soldiers were to question every decision, it could lead to division, weaken group dynamics, and decrease overall effectiveness.
As an old man, would I volunteer myself to such expectations? Well, that's why they recruit young men in their teens and early 20s. I would not classify the armed forces as simply "dumb" though. The likelihood is that you don't understand their motives so you label them as dumb. It's common to dismiss things you don't understand. I guarantee you there was logical thought behind it higher up than your pay grade ever made it.