Ok I am a Colerain Cardinal but there is one guy who was an all-around athlete and had some bad luck preventing him from making a living in sports.
Bill Vaudebrugen (If I spelled it wrong please forgive)
Bill was on a talented football team along with Roger Rodenburg, Jack Hess (my kindergarten classmate), Don and Steve Hasselbeck and Dave LaFary.
Bill played linebacker was good enough to play as a freshman at UC (the first year they were eligible. Prior to that Freshmen were not allowed to play varsity D1) and baseball as a pitcher.
He was stricken with Hodgkins disease while at UC and had to give up football but he came back to the baseball team and excelled. I talked to former UC coach Glen Sample, who told me that had he not been sick, he could have been a major league pitcher.