The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from Ohio High Schools

[Yappi]

Ohio rank to the left, National rank to the right:

1  Mike Schmidt    3B  1972  Fairview (Dayton)            43
2  Pete Rose       1B  1963  Western Hills (Cincinnati)   44
3  Ken Griffey Jr. CF  1989  Moeller (Cincinnati)         68
4  George Sisler   1B  1915  Akron (Akron)                69
5  Elmer Flick     RF  1898  Bedford (Bedford)            77
6  Jim Bunning     SP  1955  St. Xavier (Cincinnati)      86
7  Sam McDowell    SP  1961  Central Catholic (Cleveland) 151
8  Phil Niekro     SP  1964  Bridgeport (Bridgeport)      163
9  Roger Bresnahan  C  1897  Central (Toledo)             186
10 Dave Parker     RF  1973  Courter Tech (Cincinnati)    206

The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from Ohio High Schools

 

[YTOWN]

I may be wrong but I thought Sam McDowell was from Pittsburgh Central Catholic. I don't think that Cleveland Central Catholic even existed when McDowell was in high school.

 

[GCPRO]

Barry Larkin-25 Buddy Bell-27 LOL
Mark Lewis at 207-10 yrs in the majors, behind Kip Young at 200-1.5 yrs in the bigs WTH

I doubt there are too many Baseball HOFers that were the 25th best player in their state.

 

[GCPRO]

I may be wrong but I thought Sam McDowell was from Pittsburgh Central Catholic. I don't think that Cleveland Central Catholic even existed when McDowell was in high school.

You are correct. Born in Pittsburgh and went to school there

 

[YTOWN]

You are correct. Born in Pittsburgh and went to school there

Thank you sir.

 

[Over The Hills]

Barry Larkin-25 Buddy Bell-27 LOL
Mark Lewis at 207-10 yrs in the majors, behind Kip Young at 200-1.5 yrs in the bigs WTH

I doubt there are too many Baseball HOFers that were the 25th best player in their state.

Played against Lewis & Griffey.
Fantastic HS players.
Geiffey is MLB legend but Mark Lewis had a decent MLB career too.
Just wasn’t a superstar.

 

[jdizzle]

Impressive list but leaving off Larkin diminishes the credibility of this list.

I would argue that Griffey Jr. should be at #1. Arguably one of the top 5 outfielders to ever play the game, in my opinion.

 

[GCPRO]

Impressive list but leaving off Larkin diminishes the credibility of this list.

I would argue that Griffey Jr. should be at #1. Arguably one of the top 5 outfielders to ever play the game, in my opinion.

Actually Pete Rose should be #1 without argument but he's a dirtbag so I get it. I would also concur that Griffey should be ahead of Schmidt but both were great players.

 

[jdizzle]

Actually Pete Rose should be #1 without argument but he's a dirtbag so I get it. I would also concur that Griffey should be ahead of Schmidt but both were great players.

Absolutely no arguments about the above statement. All are Hall-of-Famers for a reason....not so much with Rose though. lol

 

[irish_buffalo]

The list above is garbage.

No Cy Young? Rollie Fingers was born in Steubenville (moved away as a kid). Dave Justice probably does not deserve top 10 but he does deserve to be mentioned.

As for the list we were given I understand the case for Griffey Jr. but Mike Schmidt deserves top billing. He was a 3 time MVP won a WS (WS MVP) and was a 6x golden glover.

Barry Larkin needs to be top 10.

Dave Parker should be in the HOF.

Barry Larkin Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com

Check out the latest Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More of Barry Larkin. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, draft status, bats, throws, school and more on Baseball-reference.com

www.baseball-reference.com

Dave Parker Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com

Check out the latest Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More of Dave Parker. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, draft status, bats, throws, school and more on Baseball-reference.com

www.baseball-reference.com

Mike Schmidt Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com

Check out the latest Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More of Mike Schmidt. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, draft status, bats, throws, school and more on Baseball-reference.com

www.baseball-reference.com

Ken Griffey Jr. Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com

Check out the latest Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More of Ken Griffey Jr.. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, draft status, bats, throws, school and more on Baseball-reference.com

www.baseball-reference.com

Cincinnati produced some dynamite ball players.

 

[YTOWN]

The list above is garbage.

No Cy Young? Rollie Fingers was born in Steubenville (moved away as a kid). Dave Justice probably does not deserve top 10 but he does deserve to be mentioned.

As for the list we were given I understand the case for Griffey Jr. but Mike Schmidt deserves top billing. He was a 3 time MVP won a WS (WS MVP) and was a 6x golden glover.

Barry Larkin needs to be top 10.

Dave Parker should be in the HOF.

When I first looked at the list I was thinking the same thing about Cy Young's omission especially but then I realized the topic said the list is of players that attended Ohio high schools. Then I remembered reading somewhere that Cy Young only had a 6th grade education so I assume that is why he is not on the list, maybe the others mentioned also, they did not attend Ohio high schools? Otherwise they certainly should be included.

 

[troyboy73]

Harvey Haddix?

 

[GCPRO]

Dave Justice went to Covington Latin HS(KY).

 

[Over The Hills]

Barry Larkin needs to be top 10.

Dave Parker should be in the HOF.

Cincinnati produced some dynamite ball players.

In 1980’s playing in Cincy played with or against:

Ken Griffey Jr.
Mark Lewis
Tim Naehring
Karl Tuffy Rhoades… google him
Lee May Jr.
Tommy Kramer
Chris Lutz
Jeff Hartsock
Tom Poppelwell
Pete Rose Jr.
Jay Owens

…. and many more total bad asses.

It’s a looooong list.

 

[Eagle1721971]

Ohio rank to the left, National rank to the right:

1  Mike Schmidt    3B  1972  Fairview (Dayton)            43
2  Pete Rose       1B  1963  Western Hills (Cincinnati)   44
3  Ken Griffey Jr. CF  1989  Moeller (Cincinnati)         68
4  George Sisler   1B  1915  Akron (Akron)                69
5  Elmer Flick     RF  1898  Bedford (Bedford)            77
6  Jim Bunning     SP  1955  St. Xavier (Cincinnati)      86
7  Sam McDowell    SP  1961  Central Catholic (Cleveland) 151
8  Phil Niekro     SP  1964  Bridgeport (Bridgeport)      163
9  Roger Bresnahan  C  1897  Central (Toledo)             186
10 Dave Parker     RF  1973  Courter Tech (Cincinnati)    206

The Top Ranked Baseball Players of All-Time from Ohio High Schools

What about Barry Larkin ??????????