I dont believe that is a good idea, nor do I believe that is a good idea. If high schools are successful by doing things they way OHSAA intended them to, why should those schools be penalized? Almost every D4/D3 school in the MAC would be playing up Divisions in various sports with schools 2-3 times more students, if not more. Marion Local and Coldwater would more than likely be playing Div. 1 football. Which they would not be able to compete with schools who are graduating 500-1000 kids.
Schools should play in their own divisions. I think the simply solution is that your school plays in the division based on the population the school can pull from. So if a school has Statewide open enrollment, they will be playing in the largest division. If a school has closed enrollment and only has a population of 2000 people to pull from, then of course they will play in the smaller division. I think that would stop the open enrollment.
The OH$AA doesn't care.....and have proven it over and over. They only want the $$$ They booted the only guy in the whole organization that cared anything about the kids....to just flat out admit they only wanted the money!