Professional college football

Too many overrated teams like ND & LSU. ND lost to N. Ill and LSU lost to Sothern Cal. I'm sorry, you just can't have that.
 
I suppose but a good finance guy can turn that money into more and you avoid scrambling your brains
You’re not wrong. These types of guys are also often insanely competitive though. Also hard to walk away from something when it’s been programmed into your life like it is with high level recruits now.
 
Ohio State bucking the trend of dropping programs to meet the new pay for play paradigm?

OSU is reducing the number of athletes to meet NCAA requirements but they are not reducing the number of teams and are increasing the number of scholarships offered.

 
There has always been payola in college football. They’ve found ways to buy recruits and pay players forever, but not like what we have going on today with NIL. And the player movement, which was rare until a few years ago, is pretty much out and out yearly free agency now. It’s really professional football now. You might as well just classify the players as employees and make being a student optional. And the expanded playoffs and mega-conference model is sucking out what remained of the pageantry, tradition and regionalism that made college football an entirely different animal than the NFL. Older fans like myself will lose interest, but that doesn’t matter because we’re getting out of the target demographic zone. It will be interesting if the younger fans will embrace the new college football the way past generations have, or will the popularity begin to fade over time like high school football has?
 
There has always been payola in college football. They’ve found ways to buy recruits and pay players forever, but not like what we have going on today with NIL. And the player movement, which was rare until a few years ago, is pretty much out and out yearly free agency now. It’s really professional football now. You might as well just classify the players as employees and make being a student optional. And the expanded playoffs and mega-conference model is sucking out what remained of the pageantry, tradition and regionalism that made college football an entirely different animal than the NFL. Older fans like myself will lose interest, but that doesn’t matter because we’re getting out of the target demographic zone. It will be interesting if the younger fans will embrace the new college football the way past generations have, or will the popularity begin to fade over time like high school football has?
You are spot on. College football will have to under go legal.and regulatory reforms to become "NFL Lite" to survive. As to the younger CFB followers I encounter, their fandom seems to be morphing into the gaming side of the contests rather than emotional ties to a a particular school. In a strange way, Vegas and the online gambling industry might be the catalysts to bring NIL and the transfer portal under control.
 
This might wind up killing the golden goose.
And think about the trickle down effect, especially in DII baseball. Where most powerhouse teams, will be looking to have their best players kidnapped by the Power Five and NIL, as well as other prominent programs on the DI level. If it happens like I predict. Look for the top tier DII teams becoming a nonfactor for the future. The first one who comes to mind is, the perennial national power, University of Tampa Spartans. Who routinely have major DI rosters who weren't drafted as highly as they had hoped, playing at the DII level. A mere four seasons ago, they beat the Philadelphia Phillies in a preseason exhibition game, 7-1. And the Francis Marion University, beat the defending national champion, South Carolina Gamecocks 5-2, in a regular season midweek game. The Carolina team used their entire starting lineup, that would go on to Omaha, to win back to back nattys.
 
1734284828260.png
 
Beginning of the end for the NCAA being able to set eligibility rules:
 
More former pre NIL players seeking their piece of the pie:

These revisionist lawsuits are ridiculous. You played under the rules as they were at the time. The guys coming up have a better deal, too bad. Should you be able to sue your company because starting wage is better than when you started 20 or 30 years ago?
 
I’m not sure this jumping from school to school is sustainable. IU lost I think 5 players due to lack of playing time. They just quit in the middle of the season to enter the portal. Almost their entire defense is made up of the transfers he brought with him from JMU. It’s almost like assembling a team for a pick up game.
They are going to have to come up with contracts to bind these kids to programs for multiple years.
 
These revisionist lawsuits are ridiculous. You played under the rules as they were at the time. The guys coming up have a better deal, too bad. Should you be able to sue your company because starting wage is better than when you started 20 or 30 years ago?

I agree, but one of the harsh lessons of life is that you never leave money on the table.
 
Is the NCAA Transfer Portal Obsolete??



Honestly the NCAA has been stripped of any authority to regulate anything in college sports that might restrict a player's economic freedom. In reality is the NCAA Transfer Portal now more of a courtesy as a clearinghouse for players and coaches? Is there a slippery slope where a player transfers in the middle of a season and plays for the new team?
 
In the near future, could a college team surpass a professional team in talent and payroll?

We are getting to the point that some players could make more in college than in the pros, Tim Tebow could be an example if he had played today. Is it possible for a top tier team to amass enough talent to compete with an NFL team?
 
In the near future, could a college team surpass a professional team in talent and payroll?

We are getting to the point that some players could make more in college than in the pros, Tim Tebow could be an example if he had played today. Is it possible for a top tier team to amass enough talent to compete with an NFL team?
No. Even if a college team got all the best players, they can’t compete with the age and physical maturity of an NFL roster. And of course it isn’t even remotely likely that a college team could do that.
 
In the near future, could a college team surpass a professional team in talent
No
and payroll?
No
We are getting to the point that some players could make more in college than in the pros, Tim Tebow could be an example if he had played today. Is it possible for a top tier team to amass enough talent to compete with an NFL team?
Quinn Ewers is apparently a recent example as well.
 
In the near future, could a college team surpass a professional team in talent and payroll?

We are getting to the point that some players could make more in college than in the pros, Tim Tebow could be an example if he had played today. Is it possible for a top tier team to amass enough talent to compete with an NFL team?
Has this already been done?
"The College All-Star Game, an annual preseason game, pitted a team of college all-stars against the defending Super Bowl champion NFL team. This tradition lasted for 42 years, from 1934 to 1976, with the All-Stars winning nine games and tying twice. While the NFL team ultimately dominated, with 31 wins, the game provided a platform for showcasing college talent and drew large crowds."
 
Has this already been done?
"The College All-Star Game, an annual preseason game, pitted a team of college all-stars against the defending Super Bowl champion NFL team. This tradition lasted for 42 years, from 1934 to 1976, with the All-Stars winning nine games and tying twice. While the NFL team ultimately dominated, with 31 wins, the game provided a platform for showcasing college talent and drew large crowds."
The Browns remember the game very well, as does Paul Warfield:

In the 1965 Chicago College All-Star Game, which annually pitted the reigning NFL champion against star college players, Warfield shattered his collarbone and missed the majority of the 1965 season as a result. He returned for the penultimate game of the season and caught three passes for 30 yards before bruising his collarbone, causing him to miss the final game of the regular season.
 
It's been here. Now it's legal, getting worse, and out of control. I think Texas is shelling out over $40 million in NIL next year. What a complete turnoff for us old school college football fans.
 
It's been here. Now it's legal, getting worse, and out of control. I think Texas is shelling out over $40 million in NIL next year. What a complete turnoff for us old school college football fans.
You take issue with athletes being paid for their services but take no issue with Michigan employing a pedophile and serial cyber sex criminal?

Sheeeeesh.
 
Top