There’s your answer, more non feeder talent. Same thing I’ve been saying for over a decade. Put Corey Kiner on the ‘19 team, they’re State champs. David Montgomery & Teagray Scales (who wrestled for Elder Youth team) on the ‘15 team might not have gotten them over the hump vs Colerain, but it would’ve been closer. Spencer Ware on the ‘08 & ‘09 team, they win state. One or two star athletes, that can play multiple positions, makes an enormous difference.
There were also a few years they had the bad luck of running into Colerain teams that were absolute machines. Those Colerain teams were beyond loaded but in the state semifinals & title, pissed down their leg.
As for last night, X was nearly able to pull that off bc they controlled a lot of the clock running Vollmer and Herbstreit hit some big passes on 3rd & 4th down to extend drives. Elder couldn’t run the ball consistently vs Moe and was frequently backed into 3rd & long.
IDK if things will be better in ‘25, I hope so, but we’ll just have to wait and see. There does seem to be a concerted effort to draw more kids in (not just athletes) from non traditional feeders.