Is Ignatius still open? We last played in 2004
I would love to play Lake Catholic but I don’t believe they will entertain playing Bennie.
Canfield seems like it would have to be away.
That leaves Bishop Watterson as next best option IMO
St. Ignatius is not open this week.
As you said Lake Catholic probably won't play you especially coming off a 1-9 season.
Watterson already has 5 away games as well, so I don't know if they will want to travel especially since that is a 3 hour drive probably by bus.
I don't know anything about Withrow but perhaps they would be willing to come up to play you guys for the right price, if you cover their travel costs to drive up and back. I don't know anything about Tiffin Columbian, they might be afraid to play you as well, and I think they also already have 5 away games as well, so not sure if they will want to travel either.
A Senate League team would be effectively a BYE week, but makes the most sense logistically.
An alternate option is having Hoban move the game to this week and try to find an opponent for the week you are currently scheduled to play them.
I am not sure if any PA teams are open that is a possibility I suppose.
The most realistic options are probably host a Senate League team or play at Canfield.
And if neither of those pan out then Canfield will probably host the Senate League team.