View Full Version : all city
kdonnelly4
10-05-07, 01:50 PM
now that the season is almost over who will be all city
cincysoccer2006
10-05-07, 04:27 PM
for d3 bascom and templeton are shoe ins. only question is where they will be in the all state selection in my mind
~Anonymous~
10-05-07, 04:48 PM
Here are my thoughts about players from the GMC who are possible candidates for receiving All City Honors for Division I
Lakota West- Matthew Bahner
Lakota West- Chris Dooley
Lakota East- Michael Orth
Princeton- Kevin Donnelly
Colerain- Casey Weddle
Mason- Zach Patterson
Mason- Niro Wimalasena
Sycamore- Ryan Lavigne
I think all of these players have had a tremendous influence in the success that their respective teams have experienced throughout the season.
soccerpractice
10-06-07, 03:11 PM
thoughts on DII?
radar10
10-06-07, 09:00 PM
Princeton....not a chance in purgatory that is going to happen. You have to have some form of a respectible team to get all city. Princeton has talent, some very good wins, & biggest issue was losing their coach prior to Ohio Cup & the beginning of the season, but no all city candidates. What team has best combo of Top 1o scoresrs & Top 5 in shutouts in D1? :confused:
TheTribe
10-07-07, 12:30 AM
You have to have some form of a respectible team to get all city.
Not necessarily true. WW had an all city player last year and they didn't have a winning record.
anonymous, i think you're forgetting two other gmc players that are obvious all city selections. austin morgan from colerain and seth petrey from mason.
shelto19
10-07-07, 01:58 PM
Princeton....not a chance in purgatory that is going to happen. You have to have some form of a respectible team to get all city. Princeton has talent, some very good wins, & biggest issue was losing their coach prior to Ohio Cup & the beginning of the season, but no all city candidates. What team has best combo of Top 1o scoresrs & Top 5 in shutouts in D1? :confused:
this is so not true..last time i checked the award is given to an ALL-City player not team..ha are you kidding? no all-city canadates..Kevin Donnelly plays sweeper and leads the team in goals and is currently eighth in points in the GMC..and i missed the part were our coach had to do with our portential all-city prospects
shelto19
10-07-07, 02:42 PM
8th in pts in the GMC...so? That's not all city selection...that's not even first team GMC stats.
ha..oh im sorry last year he finished 39th in points in the GMC with 7 total points....is that a lil better for ya?..oh yeah i forgot to mention he was on the first team GMC last year..with those stats...but for the sake of the disagreement i say we should discuss his talent as a player and not the stats since we both now know that they really dont matter
radar10
10-07-07, 03:28 PM
Truth of the matter...right or wrong is there will not be given the attn potentially deserved to him based on Princeton's overall perf. this season....that's the nature of the way the game is played in the selection process. Very good player yes...unfortunately overall team success was somewhat lack luster this season. On a below avg. team stats mean everything on indiv. performances.
american football
10-07-07, 04:50 PM
I would think and hope that the GMC coaches know quality players when they see them.
The truth is that some great players are in a district with a not so great team.
That does not mean they are not special players.
Each player should be judged on their own merits, not merely their team's record and/or performance.
I have seen many great players over the years that don't have great teams.
kbot513
10-07-07, 06:29 PM
Truth of the matter...right or wrong is there will not be given the attn potentially deserved to him based on Princeton's overall perf. this season....that's the nature of the way the game is played in the selection process. Very good player yes...unfortunately overall team success was somewhat lack luster this season. On a below avg. team stats mean everything on indiv. performances.
this is extremely untrue and i have an example. last year deer park was 0-15-1 and ben rascona was still i think 2nd team all state? if thats not bad team and getting good honors then i dont know what is. donnelly is sweet and he WILL get all city honors whether or not you think princeton is good. all gmc schools get someone in the mix of all conference. you are crazy to say just because of school he wont get it.
I agree that Seth Petrey of Mason will be first team all-city. He had a solid junior year but was over looked because mason was still in the FAVC. Now, that mason is in the GMC more people have had a chance to see what he can do.
cincysoccer2006
10-07-07, 09:25 PM
Ben Rascona.
plays on one of the worst teams in division 3 (since the loss of their entire team in 2005).
Team probably lost 10 of the 16 games that they played OR MORE in 2006.
2nd team all state.
You're wrong, you dont have to be on a respectable team.
eplfan87
10-08-07, 01:14 AM
CHL/Division II All-City:
Ben Rascona (Senior, Deer Park)
Michael Rakoczy (Junior, Finneytown)
Jeff Smoker (Senior, Finneytown)
Aaron Schultz (Senior, Finneytown)
Nate Bryson (Sophomore, Finneytown)
Kevin Siegle (Sophomore, Finneytown)
Nate Bascom (Senior, Madeira)
Ian Templeton (Senior, Madeira)
Mitch White (Junior, Mariemont)
Alex Kamphause (Senior, Wyoming)
David Carter (Junior, Wyoming)
John Zelek (Senior, Indian Hill)
Brinn? (the one that plays in the back, Senior, Indian Hill)
Tyler Stone (Senior, Roger Bacon)
cincysoccer2006
10-08-07, 03:18 AM
lol kbot my bad i didnt even notice ud said something about ben i didnt read urs thoroughly.
epl ur giving ur team too much cred i think. 5 on a first team is unheard of from what i can remember. 4 is the max im pretty sure
eplfan87
10-08-07, 09:42 AM
I never said that they were all on first team. I just stated that I think these are the people who will go All-City. If you would like me to divide them into what I think their respective teams will be, I can do that.
kbot513
10-08-07, 03:32 PM
lol its cool cincy. and epl, i was under the impression that deer park and madeira are D3? or im i wrong? im really not sure.
cincysoccer2006
10-08-07, 06:35 PM
in order to be all city, you have to be first team all league. that is atleast the rule i have heard from AD's and coaches in the past.....
kbot ur right. He's speculating on both i think.
in order to be all city, you have to be first team all league. that is atleast the rule i have heard from AD's and coaches in the past.....
kbot ur right. He's speculating on both i think.
I'm not sure about that because last year Vasilis Vasilakis from Finneytown was All-City but 2nd team all-CHL I believe.
acmilan13
10-08-07, 09:23 PM
You can be nominated for all city honors as long as you attain 1st or 2nd team in your league.
Deer Park, Madeira, & Mariemont are all D3 but I think eplfan was including them in his list maybe since they are CHL teams.
eplfan87
10-08-07, 10:30 PM
yes, if you look at the top it says "CHL/Division II All-City"
cincysoccer2006
10-09-07, 01:28 AM
I'm not sure about that because last year Vasilis Vasilakis from Finneytown was All-City but 2nd team all-CHL I believe.
surprising. i know that nobody from my school, or my league i am pretty sure, has ever been all city without being all league 1st team (with the rare exception of alex mannion from seven hills making all city without being all league, go figure)
sportsguy99
10-09-07, 07:51 AM
MSN....Mr. Spoertsguy needs date to homecoming this weekend. Tough when someone speaks the truth. Also, MSN...you can't vote for yourself.:crush:
Let's try keeping threads on topic just once. :thumb:
charger09
10-11-07, 10:29 AM
CHL/Division II All-City:
Ben Rascona (Senior, Deer Park)
Michael Rakoczy (Junior, Finneytown)
Jeff Smoker (Senior, Finneytown)
Aaron Schultz (Senior, Finneytown)
Nate Bryson (Sophomore, Finneytown)
Kevin Siegle (Sophomore, Finneytown)
Nate Bascom (Senior, Madeira)
Ian Templeton (Senior, Madeira)
Mitch White (Junior, Mariemont)
Alex Kamphause (Senior, Wyoming)
David Carter (Junior, Wyoming)
John Zelek (Senior, Indian Hill)
Brinn? (the one that plays in the back, Senior, Indian Hill)
Tyler Stone (Senior, Roger Bacon)
You have to be joking. I agree that Finneytown has a nice defense but Bryson and Siegle on the all city team as sophomores is not going to happen. I have attended 4-5 Finneytown games and have seen they are good but not all city YET. Rakoczy and Smoker are definites, but even Schultz is a stretch for all city. Stats help a lot and those three others from FT don't have many. Kamphaus will not get all city and neither should Carter.
Statechamps02
10-11-07, 02:45 PM
So are all those kids from the CHL going to be division 2 all-city? If so, you've got to be kidding me. 14 players from one league would be unheard of and would never happen. Now, they might make CHL 1st or 2nd team.
chelsea10
10-12-07, 12:13 PM
I agree with StateChamps all of those players will not be first team there are multiple leagues with studs such as the CHL. The committee has a tough selection this year. We'll wait and see who gets chosen
eplfan87
10-12-07, 03:25 PM
First off, there are only 10 players from Division 2 Teams listed above. Madeira, Deerpark, and Mariemont are all Division 3. Also, last year we had at least 8 players from the CHL go All-City. I don't think that 10 is far off from 8, do you? What I was trying to state at the top of the list was that there were CHL teams as well as other Division 2 teams listed below, such as Roger Bacon. They are not in the CHL but are in Division 2. Sorry that it was confusing. I also think that if you did not know that 4 of the teams listed were in Division 3, you don't need to be commenting on anything about the CHL. I stick with believing that all the players above DESERVE to be All-City. I am not saying they all will, but I think that they deserve it. I will say that they ALL WILL be on 1st, 2nd, or 3rd (Honorable Mention) teams in their respective leagues. So, Statechamps02, please go back to commenting on all your Division 1 threads, and leave us poor Division 2 and 3 people alone.
Thank you.
Statechamps02
10-12-07, 06:08 PM
First off, I knew what you were getting at...whether it was D2 or D3, I don't care. All I know is that you won't get 10 from the CHL to be all-city regardless of how great they are. Coaches vote for it and they wouldn't all vote for 10 players to get in. I think 8 is an above average mark. Now I agree with you that 10+players from the CHL may deserve it, ---- it could be the top 20 players in the city and they wouldn't give you 10. That's just how it goes. I've been around the system to know it. So please, before you bash me about knowing only about D1...which you are 80% right about...just be smart about knowing how the system works. It is unfair, but that's life. That's just like comparing the greatest offensive player vs the greatest defensive player...who is gonna win that battle?? obviously the offensive player regardless of how great the defender is, that's just how it goes.
Bengals12
10-14-07, 10:58 PM
I doubt all those people from Ftown will get All city? I believe smoker and maybe schultz will get some sort of all city, The other two will prolly only get all chl. No one from the 11-2-2 Reading team?
cincysoccer2006
10-15-07, 02:45 PM
rakoczy will too. and lets keep in mind that the CHL had an immense amount of talent last year, with Dan Ibarra, Zach Winters, Nate Bascom, Ian Templeton, Matt Ellsworth, Josh Greene, David Kreihbiel, Jose Combs, Hansey (forget first name sorry), Jeff Smoker, Vasilis Vasilakis, Finneytowns #7 and #8, and those are just form the big 3 teams and not even all the good players on each team. Last year's CHL was unreal.
jackhammer19
10-15-07, 03:35 PM
rakoczy will too. and lets keep in mind that the CHL had an immense amount of talent last year, with Dan Ibarra, Zach Winters, Nate Bascom, Ian Templeton, Matt Ellsworth, Josh Greene, David Kreihbiel, Jose Combs, Hansey (forget first name sorry), Jeff Smoker, Vasilis Vasilakis, Finneytowns #7 and #8, and those are just form the big 3 teams and not even all the good players on each team. Last year's CHL was unreal.
agreed. The CHL was absolutely loaded last year.
its bot too shabby this year either, especially defensively.
I doubt all those people from Ftown will get All city? I believe smoker and maybe schultz will get some sort of all city, The other two will prolly only get all chl. No one from the 11-2-2 Reading team?
Who does reading play outside of the CHL that is a quality team and im pretty sure thats where all of their losses and ties come from. and from what ive heard both of their league ties (wyoming and finneytown) they were both 1-1 ties with readings goal coming off of a penalty kick.
Pitch Fork
10-15-07, 10:13 PM
You have missed:
Freshman, Clay Nelson, Reading
Senior, David Honerlaw, Reading
Senior, Dustin Hinkel, Reading
Pitch Fork
10-15-07, 10:21 PM
Reading played several quality teams. They beat New Miami when they were both undefeated, I thought they tied Maderia and I think they beat wyoming. The mariemont game was a joke - can't get a good referee at reading fields... even if you paid them - the line judge referee was running down the sidelines pulling up his drawers- he was that bad. Didn't see the indian hill game, but heard it was sad - reading just did not come to play.. and the Finneytown from what I read above - is sour grapes... regardless of why they tied... there were still 80 minutes of unanswered goals from Finneytown... it was a very evenly matched game - and Finneytown lost their cool and clocked someone in the head in the box... to keep him from scoring. The Penalty kick was a good one to be called on, it was not a give me....
Statechamps02
10-15-07, 10:38 PM
You're crazy if you think a freshman is going to make all-city, unless he has 25 goals and 10 assists.
Pitch Fork
10-15-07, 10:44 PM
From what I saw from him this year, Clay deserves all-city. I heard he is a ranked goalie - going into the season? But, I think depending on how far Reading goes in post-season. Which I am not saying should be considered until after the first 2.. and on... I would think he has a good chance. He is outstanding.
Reading tied wyoming on a very touchy call inside the box, while wyoming led for the last 5 minutes of the first half and all of the second half until the call with under two minutes left. wyoming dominated the game with more opportunities but couldnt capitalize and reading had very ferw shots from 20 yards and in.
Bengals12
10-16-07, 09:42 PM
Pitch fork, Reading did not even play new miami this year, they did however play little miami. The freshman nelson is a goalie, and is very talented, but I dont know about all city possibly all CHL though, since besides smoker I have not seen or heard abotu any other goalies from the CHL(dont really know much about this years goalies so dont go crazy if Im wrong like everyone on here likes to do)
futbolconvert
10-17-07, 05:51 PM
does anyone think anyone from turpin will make it?
MilfordEagles02
10-17-07, 05:55 PM
Anyone have thoughts on any FAVC players making All City? All I saw were GMC on the one list and the rest are D2, and D3.
Eagles21
10-17-07, 07:47 PM
Ryan Grothaus from Milford perhaps? 11 goals, 9 assists, one of the focal points of Milford's offense.
radar10
10-17-07, 08:51 PM
Grothaus: Great player w/ out question & deserves honors. Understands the game & strategy as well as anyone
Tommy George..... the person who needs & deserves the most accolades.
Tyler Huerkamp...like a thief in the night....can score at will.
Milfords defense......2 years in a row have graduated some of the best in class yet each year the new kids step up. This Milford team is not about one stud like many GCL teams especially in the land of "purple".....never has been nor will be. :hello:
futbolconvert
10-17-07, 09:34 PM
hey what does everyone think of robert taylor, craig cantor, and alec gates goin all city. they were prolly a huge part in turpins success during the season. they didn't produce agains WW but they didnt have any luck on there side that night and WW played a really good game. Post any comments about thes three people
TheTribe
10-18-07, 12:19 AM
Luke Spencer of WW. Went all city last year. Better stats on a better team this year. Definitely deserves all city again.
MilfordEagles02
10-18-07, 05:25 AM
What # is Luke Spencer? I don't remember anyone that was that much of a dominant force when we played WW.
TheTribe
10-18-07, 07:02 AM
What # is Luke Spencer? I don't remember anyone that was that much of a dominant force when we played WW.
#2 I believe. I wan't at the WW milford game so i don't know how he played but he was on a mission against Turpin and I hope that carries over into this Milford game.
BravesBeast08
10-18-07, 07:32 AM
John Zelek and Ryan Brinn should be first team all city from Indian Hill..they led IH to a share of the CHL crown for the first time in years
Statechamps02
10-18-07, 09:33 AM
Grothaus: Great player w/ out question & deserves honors. Understands the game & strategy as well as anyone
Tommy George..... the person who needs & deserves the most accolades.
Tyler Huerkamp...like a thief in the night....can score at will.
Milfords defense......2 years in a row have graduated some of the best in class yet each year the new kids step up. This Milford team is not about one stud like many GCL teams especially in the land of "purple".....never has been nor will be. :hello:
And you had to quote Elder why? I don't think they have 50 goals on the season for no reason. I know Meyer didn't score 50. They have 3 of the top 8 point leaders in the GCL(12 teams). I'd say that is pretty good. Not only that, they have a payer who has 2nd most assists in the city and a keeper tied for most shutouts in the city(Unless you count the Mason keepers together). So they must have at least a decent defense. So I don't believe they are about one stud. He is definitely a go to man that produces. So I'll say Meyer(F) and Corbett(M) from Elder with Hurley(GK) and Bertke(D) as maybe's.
Statechamps02
10-18-07, 09:35 AM
Kuhlmann from Colerain should be on that list as well.
sportsguy99
10-18-07, 01:38 PM
Grothaus: Great player w/ out question & deserves honors. Understands the game & strategy as well as anyone
Tommy George..... the person who needs & deserves the most accolades.
Tyler Huerkamp...like a thief in the night....can score at will.
Milfords defense......2 years in a row have graduated some of the best in class yet each year the new kids step up. This Milford team is not about one stud like many GCL teams especially in the land of "purple".....never has been nor will be. :hello:
I agree with Grothaus and possibly Huerkamp, but I'm not sure if George will get it yet this year.
And you will get ragged on for your comment about Elder here, but i agree with that statement as well. They will try and name off a list of other players they have, but everybody knows they are a 1 man show.
I can't believe i actually agree with Radar here. Don't know what this world is coming to haha.
Statechamps02
10-18-07, 02:20 PM
Well, we will find out soon then. Stats speak for themselves.
Eagles21
10-18-07, 03:01 PM
Yeah, Tommy George doesn't deserve all-city. He makes small mental mistakes(I believe it was the Princeton game where he completely messed up on a free kick), and was only outstanding the second half of the season. Ryan Grothaus is in my opinion the one from Milford to go All-city.
MilfordEagles02
10-18-07, 03:22 PM
#2 I believe. I wan't at the WW milford game so i don't know how he played but he was on a mission against Turpin and I hope that carries over into this Milford game.
I wasn't bashing on him, from what I hear he is a pretty good player. I just don't remember him when we played WW. We'll see how things go Saturday.
WHITE SHOES 07
10-18-07, 03:58 PM
Grothaus, Huerkamp, and the defender who wears #2 should all get
consideration. Michelson might get a look. Is it true that Milford has 8 or 9 Juniors starting on it ? Also I've heard that they are all finally healthy, seems that every game some key player was out with an injury. Of course they were all healthy against Loveland and lost at home so go WW.
TheTribe
10-18-07, 04:00 PM
I wasn't bashing on him, from what I hear he is a pretty good player. I just don't remember him when we played WW. We'll see how things go Saturday.
I know. He just didn't play well against Milford the first time and I just hope that doesn't happen again.
MilfordEagles02
10-18-07, 04:10 PM
Grothaus, Huerkamp, and the defender who wears #2 should all get
consideration. Michelson might get a look. Is it true that Milford has 8 or 9 Juniors starting on it ? Also I've heard that they are all finally healthy, seems that every game some key player was out with an injury. Of course they were all healthy against Loveland and lost at home so go WW.
Let's see.. Tyler Huerkamp, Nathan Hudson, Ben Jones, Ryan Grothaus, Peter Michelson, Danny Haberer are they typical starting Juniors. So 6, the rest are all seniors. Brady was the only key player that was injured that I know of. We're pumped for the game Saturday, sure WW will be also. Should be an exciting game.
WHITE SHOES 07
10-18-07, 04:17 PM
Is George a senior ?
radar10
10-18-07, 05:15 PM
I agree with Grothaus and possibly Huerkamp, but I'm not sure if George will get it yet this year.
And you will get ragged on for your comment about Elder here, but i agree with that statement as well. They will try and name off a list of other players they have, but everybody knows they are a 1 man show.
I can't believe i actually agree with Radar here. Don't know what this world is coming to haha.
Hey now...Sportsguy finally drank the purple Kool Aid & has come full circle. Nothing like a new believer!!!!! Jump on the bandwagon!!:cool:
Eagles21
10-18-07, 05:16 PM
Tommy George is a junior.
radar10
10-18-07, 06:11 PM
Let's see.. Tyler Huerkamp, Nathan Hudson, Ben Jones, Ryan Grothaus, Peter Michelson, Danny Haberer are they typical starting Juniors. So 6, the rest are all seniors. Brady was the only key player that was injured that I know of. We're pumped for the game Saturday, sure WW will be also. Should be an exciting game.
Five Sr's on the team w/ 4 starting. Will return 7 starters next fall.
MilfordEagles02
10-18-07, 07:21 PM
Tommy George is a junior.
Whoops, forgot Tommy. My b.
george definately does not deserve all-city. he has had some solid games but there are several keepers in the city that are better than him. if i were to choose two goalies for all-city it would be austin morgan from colerain and Giradot from west. i've seen both play several times this year and have looked very impressive.
Princeton1
10-18-07, 09:02 PM
I agree with all the selections for 1st team GMC except Mike Orth. Central defender, I don't even remember him on the field, how's that all league? At least give honors to Colerain striker with 14 goals or Steve Owens at Princeton.
WHITE SHOES 07
10-19-07, 03:46 PM
Let's see.. Tyler Huerkamp, Nathan Hudson, Ben Jones, Ryan Grothaus, Peter Michelson, Danny Haberer are they typical starting Juniors. So 6, the rest are all seniors. Brady was the only key player that was injured that I know of. We're pumped for the game Saturday, sure WW will be also. Should be an exciting game.
Hey Eagle, I did a little investigating ( thanks SC ) and wasn't Bayerl in a leg cast of some type? Didn't Bender have the flu, Hudson, Huerkamp & Brune leg problems, Michelson shoulders or back issues in which all missed playing time. I guess you'd say none of them are key players. I just want to make sure everyone is healthy if they can make it past WW before the mighty GCL smacks them down again. Nice knowing the right info about your own team.
dgains15
10-19-07, 05:08 PM
Also George was injured for almost 3 quarters of the season, played against Mason West Indian Hill and others injured with a quad injury, played the last 4-5 games in full health. Haberer has also been struggiling with respiratory problems and Hurkamp has had problems with his vision in his right eye, still to this day very unfortunate
MilfordEagles02
10-19-07, 06:00 PM
Hey Eagle, I did a little investigating ( thanks SC ) and wasn't Bayerl in a leg cast of some type? Didn't Bender have the flu, Hudson, Huerkamp & Brune leg problems, Michelson shoulders or back issues in which all missed playing time. I guess you'd say none of them are key players. I just want to make sure everyone is healthy if they can make it past WW before the mighty GCL smacks them down again. Nice knowing the right info about your own team.
Let's not put words into my mouth. I forgot about Bayerl's injury from pre-season along with Tommy's quad issues and the rest really aren't major problems. They all played exceptionally well with the problems, it's been a long season. Heaven forbid I forgot about a few things. :rolleyes:
Princeton1
10-19-07, 08:10 PM
Yeah, how does George make all-city. I play with him for club and he is a real solid keeper but not the best I've seen this year. Inconsistent, K-Donnely chipped Tommy on a free kick while he was arguing with the ref over a call. Blunder one of worst I've seen from a keeper in a big game.
dgains15
10-19-07, 10:48 PM
haha..you make it sound so much worse than it really was..tommy set the ball down about 10-12 yards away from any princeton player and didnt say one word to the ref the only thing that he was pissed about was that his team made bad foul right outside of the box not even saying a word to the ref..and when he was walking back they bent it around the one person wall that hadnt even been set up...just bad communication by tommy and his defense..not going to say it is not his fault though..definatly not the dumbest thing that i have ever seen..but it still was a big game which is true
soccerwiseman
10-20-07, 12:33 AM
I think we are forgetting Scott Burnette. Perhaps the most consitently brilliant player in cincinnati.
ha no doubt scotty is a good player but he doesnt deserve all city honors. especially if niro wimalesena, patterson, and petrey get all city (like they should) i dont know how coaches will vote four players all city from the same team...but thats beside the point. scott is a good center mid, consistent and smart, but i dont think he has the game breaker talent to be all city
Maxsoccer6
10-20-07, 10:28 AM
I agree with all the selections for 1st team GMC except Mike Orth. Central defender, I don't even remember him on the field, how's that all league? At least give honors to Colerain striker with 14 goals or Steve Owens at Princeton.
Orth should be all-city, he was last year and is still playing just as well
Princeton1
10-20-07, 04:09 PM
Wow, didn't realize Orth was all-city last year, may have exaggerated a bit. He's a solid player but with the defense of Mason, Colerain, and West along with Donnely, don't know if he cracks top 4 defenders.
My all GMC defense: Niro, Donnely, Dooley, one of Colerain's 30 year olds?
midfield: Weddle, Patterson, Lavigne, Bahner
striker: Kuhlmann, Herrington
Statechamps02
10-21-07, 01:46 PM
I hear Niro was D-1 player of the year.
ALLsport00
10-21-07, 04:33 PM
When do all divisions come out and how exactly is it decided?
Statechamps02
10-21-07, 05:02 PM
I know the voting took place Saturday morning for D1...don't know about the others. Each coach can submit up to 4 players he thinks is eligible for all-city and the coaches vote on it. I think the coaches even get up and talk about the players they have nominated from their team.
TheTribe
10-21-07, 07:10 PM
Yea, and I think all the coaches can talk about all the nominees, not just their own.
soccerpractice
10-21-07, 08:29 PM
I believe all of the divisions have already voted
Striker23
10-21-07, 10:06 PM
After milford and the kid with the throw in beat us again ... I am putting him ini for for all city.. plays defense a leads in assists... tough combo
Statechamps02
10-21-07, 10:57 PM
Yea, and I think all the coaches can talk about all the nominees, not just their own.
Yeah, they get 2 minutes to talk about their own and a minute or so to talk about anyone else they wish to.
TheTribe
10-21-07, 11:07 PM
Yeah, they get 2 minutes to talk about their own and a minute or so to talk about anyone else they wish to.
Ok. I don't think they publicize it but i'd be interested in seeing the rank of the players by the coaches vote.
Statechamps02
10-22-07, 09:43 PM
Would be nice to see. Go get some insider info from a coach.
cincysoccercoach
10-23-07, 12:44 PM
The lists of the coaches vote are confidential and don't leave the room. Each coach gets 3 minutes to talk about all their players and 1 minute to comment on other players they have seen play.
The coaches opinions are very important and can decide who makes the top spots.
Generally they don't hand out the voting until every team is out of the tournament or they just tell the players from their team who made All SW Ohio. Most coaches feel it is a distraction to the team to announce it early because they are individual awards and players not recognized could get upset. It may affect their play in the tournament if they feel slighted.
The voting for all divisions and genders took place last Saturday.
TheTribe
10-23-07, 01:41 PM
thanks for the info. so a coach would know the rank of his own player(s) and could tell them at his own discretion how high they were in the voting if he saw fit? coaches know the rank and not just the list who made it, right?
soccerpractice
10-27-07, 11:42 AM
Coaches do know the rank of where the players fell in All-City voting.
A little D-II action here. Both Kamphaus and Carter from wyoming made it. Carter being second team all CHL. thoughts?
titan32
11-02-07, 07:34 PM
A little D-II action here. Both Kamphaus and Carter from wyoming made it. thoughts?
nice job dude. glad to see you make it. are you going to play at the next level? any plans on where you're going to college?
ALLsport00
11-09-07, 03:15 PM
is it posted anywhere?
Possibly, Im not quite sure yet. Ive talked to the Case Western Coach and hes expressed interst so just gotta go with the flow ya know
vBulletin® v3.6.4, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.