I think this article lays out the crux of the problem. And you see this debate playing out everywhere including on the pages of Yappi:
pjmedia.com
Risk Tolerant America sees the rising number of Wuhan-infected and the declining number of daily deaths, and thinks, “We’re past the worst. Time to get back to work.”
Zero Risk America looks at those exact same facts and concludes it’s time for another lockdown.
Our problem as a nation is that our federalist system has become so centralized that there’s less and less elbow room for people of differing opinions. Two Americas, but increasingly one set of overly stringent rules.
These two groups are getting farther apart and I for one really don't want to live in their zero risk, chicken little world anymore. They can take a lot away with apparent impunity. And it's not just school extracurricular activities it's almost everything you might value or enjoy.
In the long run the only solution might be to privatize extracurricular activities and remove them from local school districts. This would include athletics, Art & Music. The gap would be filled by private company's and non-profit associations of people that offer these activities to local youth. If they focused on community connections you might see just as many people attending recitals, concerts and sporting events as you see now. This would be a mix of profit and non-profit organizations.
Private schools might explode in popularity if they truly separated themselves from the OHSAA. Club sports might flourish and be very popular within a community.
People who know my posting know I'm a big booster of public school athletics. But if they cancel the fall season which will likely lead to them canceling the winter season then school districts can no longer be trusted with the responsibility of managing these activities. There are kids who are working towards scholarships. For them this is more then a game.