Who's your high School All- Time Squad?

Walsh Jesuit:
106 Don Horning: 2X SC, 2X NCAA AA
113 Jimmy Johnson 2X SC
120 Adam Plouse: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
126 Johnni Dijulius: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup
132 Sonny Marchette: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr Champ
138 Nate Skonieczny: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
145 Clint Musser: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Cadet & Jr Runnerup, NCAA Runnerup
152 Joe Heskett: 3X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, NCAA Champ, 2X NCAA Runnerup
160 David Rella: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr 3rd x 2
170 Markus Mollica: 2X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, 2X NCAA Champ, 4X NCAA All America
182 Mike Pucillo: 1X SC, 2X Runnerup, NCAA Champ, NCAA Runnerup
195 Jeff Knupp: 3X SC, Fargo Cadet Champ
220 Viktor Sveda: 1X SC, Fargo Jr Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
HVY ?? Matt Tyla: Ironman placer

Honorable mention:
Rich Robusto: 2X SC
Josh Zupancic: 1X SC, 3X State Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
Alex Mackall: 1X SC, 2X State Runnerup, Fargo Jr and Cadet FS All America, 2X NCAA Qualifier
 
Last edited:
PARMA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL All-Time Squad
106: Jim Linx, State Champion
113: Chuck Sanfilippo, 2nd State
120: Bob Mason, State Champion, 3x SP, MAC Champion at Ohio University
126: Sal Corrao, 5th State
132: Pat Mason, 4th State
138: Jason Duganier, 3rd State
145: Devin Marrone, 8th State
152: Bruce Trammell, 3rd State, 2x All-American and NCAA Finalist at Ohio University
160: Ken Dabrowski, 2nd State
170: Harry Houska, State Champion, NCAA Champion and 2-time Finalist at Ohio University
182: Steve Shivak, 3rd State
195: Justin Halaska, 2x SP
220: Bruce Wolfe, 4th State
285: Greg Dabrowski, State Qualifier and NJCAA Runner-up at CCC-West
Other accomplished performers:
Robert Klubnick, 3rd State; Rich Fleming, MAC Champion at Miami University in Ohio; Tony Rocco, 6th State, Mike Lewis, 7th State; Marc Buchanan, NJCAA runner-up at CCC-West and NCAA qualifier at Ohio University.
 
Massillon Perry

106- David Bavery - 2xSC, RU, 3rd
113- Jose Rodriguez- 2xSC, RU
120- Sam White- 2xSC, RU
126- Jason Johnstone- 2xSC, RU
132- Zach Dailey- 2xSC, 4th
138- Thomas Straughn- 2xSC, 4th, 5th
145- Dustin Schlatter- 4xSC
152- John Foster- SC
160- David Carr- 4xSC
170- Steve Luke- 3xSC, RU
182- Nick Heflin- SC,RU
195- JoJo Tayse- 2xSC, 5th
220- I wonder if Max Millin ever wrestled here before moving to Hvy? If so he is the guy. 3rd, with a probable championship this year.
HWY- Jason Wise- 2x RU
 
Wrestlingfan21 said:
Massillon Perry

106- David Bavery - 2xSC, RU, 3rd
113- Jose Rodriguez- 2xSC, RU
120- Sam White- 2xSC, RU
126- Jason Johnstone- 2xSC, RU
132- Zach Dailey- 2xSC, 4th
138- Thomas Straughn- 2xSC, 4th, 5th
145- Dustin Schlatter- 4xSC
152- John Foster- SC
160- David Carr- 4xSC
170- Steve Luke- 3xSC, RU
182- Nick Heflin- SC,RU
195- JoJo Tayse- 2xSC, 5th
220- I wonder if Max Millin ever wrestled here before moving to Hvy? If so he is the guy. 3rd, with a probable championship this year.
HWY- Jason Wise- 2x RU
Click to expand...
On JakesWrestling, looks like all 4 yrs. @hwvy.
 
pcbuck said:
Walsh Jesuit:
106 Don Horning: 2X SC, 2X NCAA AA
113 Jimmy Johnson 2X SC
120 Adam Plouse: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
126 Johnni Dijulius: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup
132 Sonny Marchette: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr Champ
138 Nate Skonieczny: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
145 Clint Musser: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Cadet & Jr Runnerup, NCAA Runnerup
152 Joe Heskett: 3X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, NCAA Champ, 2X NCAA Runnerup
160 David Rella: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr 3rd x 2
170 Markus Mollica: 2X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, 2X NCAA Champ, 4X NCAA All America
182 Mike Pucillo: 1X SC, 2X Runnerup, NCAA Champ, NCAA Runnerup
195 Jeff Knupp: 3X SC, Fargo Cadet Champ
220 Viktor Sveda: 1X SC, Fargo Jr Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
HVY ?? Matt Tyla: Ironman placer

Honorable mention:
Rich Robusto: 2X SC
Josh Zupancic: 1X SC, 3X State Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
Click to expand...

I realize both St Eds and SPG's honorable mention teams can beat most of our all time teams... But I might take this one over both of them for a first team.
 
TheFan1 said:
I realize both St Eds and SPG's honorable mention teams can beat most of our all time teams... But I might take this one over both of them for a first team.
Click to expand...
Depends, at what point in the wrestlers careers are they wrestling this theoretical dual? For instance Mike Pucillo’s NCAA accolades are a lot more rare than his high school ones. For college he’d be awfully high up on the list, for high school I’d pick more guys over him. Same for Ryan Bertin of Ed’s. What weights are they using? The stupid new ones that take out a middle weight and put in an upper weight really hurts Graham for instance. And is the weight you are listed at have to be that years version of themselves? So Dustin Schlatter at Graham only wrestled 112 and 125. So if he’s in the lineup at 125 it’s sophomore Dustin? I’m not sure you could fit all nine 4 time State Champs Graham has had in the lineup without some bumping .
 
Last edited:
It's like the old Soviet Union teams...Many times, you might have to beat a world champion just to make their lineup. Some of the Graham, St. Eds wrestle-offs just to make the all-time team would be epic. I say...too bad.:)
 
PARMA HEIGHTS VALLEY FORGE HIGH SCHOOL All-Time Squad
106: Steve Kibler, 3rd State
113: Greg Young, 3rd State
120: Ken Masica, State Champion
126: Kyle Bentley, State Champion, NCAA Qualifier at Kent State
132: Bob Lade, State Champion, 2x SP
138: Jim Horning, 3rd State
145: Woody Barry, State Champion
152: Roger Johnson, 2nd State
160: Dennis Coupe, State Champion, 2x SP
170: Al Fair, 4th State, NCAA III runner-up and 2x All-American at Ashland University
182: Todd Smith, 4th State
195: Mark Horvath, 5th State
220: Ron Cooper, 2nd State
285: James Meder, 2nd State, 2x SP
Other accomplished performers:
Fred Hague, 2nd State; Gary Barylski, 2nd State; Larry Lampa, 3rd State; Tom Cahal, 4th State; Chad Gross, NCAA III Champion at John Carroll; Casey Yackin 5th State and NCAA Qualifier at Ohio University; Daryl Stumph, 3x All-American at Hiram College.
 
baseballfan1972 said:
PARMA PADUA FRANCISCAN HIGH SCHOOL All-Time Squad
106: Ricky Randazzo, 2x SP, 2x NCAA II All-American at Mercyhurst
113: Tony DeCesare, 2-time State Runner-up, 3x SP
120: Bobby Mason, State Runner-up, 2x SP, NCAA II Qualifier at Ashland
126: Jesse Clark, State Champion, 2x SP, NCAA II Runner-up at Ashland
132: Brent Fickel, State Champion, 4x SP, NCAA II All-American at Ashland
138: Pat McLemore, 2-time State Champion, MAC Champion at Northern Illinois
145: Kurt Gross, State Champion, 3x MAC Champion at Kent State
152: Kyle Kaminski, State Runner-up, 3x SP
160: Eric Fasnacht, State Runner-up, 2x SP
170: Gerred Tolson, State Runner-up
182: Jan Rakoczy, 3rd State
195: Pete Abraham, 4th State, NCAA II Qualifier at Ashland
220: Aldo Campea, 4th State, 2x NCAA II All-American at Ashland
285: Brian Keck, State Champion, NJCAA National Champion
Other highly-accomplished performers:
Steve LaScala, 3rd State; Dave Morell, 2x NCAA II All-American at Ashland; Shane Friery, State Champion, 2x SP; Andrew Romanchik, 3rd State, 3x SP, 2x NCAA Qualifier at Ohio University; Jeff Durkin, State Runner-up, 2x SP; Sal Monachino, State Runner-up; Todd Gaydosh, 1x SP, NCAA III Qualifier at John Carroll.
Click to expand...
I believe that 126 Jesse Clark was a state champ as a sr.
 
Not my school but I was intrigued by what a lineup would look like so here’s my Saint Paris Graham lineup:

106- Jim Jordan 4 time SC
113 - Jeff Jordan 4 time SC
120 - Kyle Ott 3 time SC(last one at SPG)
126 - Dustin Schlatter 4 time SC(1st 2 at SPG)
132 - Mitch Moore 4 time SC
138 - David Taylor 4 time SC
145 - Micah Jordan 4 time SC
152 - CP Schlatter 4 time SC(last 2 at SPG)
160 - Bo Jordan 4 time SC
171 - Alex Marinelli 4 time SC
182 - Avery Zerkle SC, RU
195 - Max Thomusseit 2 time SC
215 - Joe Dennis SC(4th, 2nd, 5th, 1st) won senior nats
285 - Adam Walls (6th, 4th, 2nd, 3rd in D1 at beavercreek)

Notable backups
3 time SC’s - Ty Morgan, Cameron Doggett, Ben Jordan, Isaac Jordan, Felipe Martinez, Ryan Taylor, Kyle Lawson, Rocky Jordan
2 time SC’s - Josh Wooten, Dave Erwin, Aaron Hart, Zach Neibert, Nick Brascetta, Eli Seipel, Brent Moore
 
Last edited:
Not my school but I was intrigued by what a lineup would look like so here’s my Saint Paris Graham lineup:

106- Jim Jordan 4 time SC
113 - Jeff Jordan 4 time SC
120 - Kyle Ott 3 time SC(last one at SPG)
126 - Dustin Schlatter 4 time SC(1st 2 at SPG)
132 - Mitch Moore 4 time SC
138 - David Taylor 4 time SC
145 - Micah Jordan 4 time SC
152 - CP Schlatter 4 time SC(last 2 at SPG)
160 - Bo Jordan 4 time SC
171 - Alex Marinelli 4 time SC
182 - Dan Bair SC
195 - Max Thomusseit 2 time SC
215 - Joe Dennis SC(4th, 2nd, 5th, 1st) won senior nats
285 - Adam Walls (6th, 4th, 2nd, 3rd in D1 at beavercreek)

Notable backups
3 time SC’s - Ty Morgan, Cameron Doggett, Ben Jordan, Isaac Jordan, Felipe Martinez, Ryan Taylor, Kyle Lawson, Rocky Jordan
2 time SC’s - Josh Wooten, Dave Erwin, Aaron Hart, Zach Neibert, Nick Brascetta, Eli Seipel, Brent Moore
[/QUOTE]
9 four time SCs Winn’s IMO albeit Div 2. It’s still lines up with Ed’s IMO. Very impressive.
 
“
Notable backups
3 time SC’s - Ty Morgan, Cameron Doggett, Ben Jordan, Isaac Jordan, Felipe Martinez, Ryan Taylor, Kyle Lawson, Rocky Jordan
2 time SC’s - Josh Wooten, Dave Erwin, Aaron Hart, Zach Neibert, Nick Brascetta, Eli Seipel, Brent Moore”
That’s a heck of a statement/qualification to make. Most rosters in this thread can’t make that claim.
 
Joe Daugherty said:
Not my school but I was intrigued by what a lineup would look like so here’s my Saint Paris Graham lineup:

106- Jim Jordan 4 time SC
113 - Jeff Jordan 4 time SC
120 - Kyle Ott 3 time SC(last one at SPG)
126 - Dustin Schlatter 4 time SC(1st 2 at SPG)
132 - Mitch Moore 4 time SC
138 - David Taylor 4 time SC
145 - Micah Jordan 4 time SC
152 - CP Schlatter 4 time SC(last 2 at SPG)
160 - Bo Jordan 4 time SC
171 - Alex Marinelli 4 time SC
182 - Dan Bair SC
195 - Max Thomusseit 2 time SC
215 - Joe Dennis SC(4th, 2nd, 5th, 1st) won senior nats
285 - Adam Walls (6th, 4th, 2nd, 3rd in D1 at beavercreek)

Notable backups
3 time SC’s - Ty Morgan, Cameron Doggett, Ben Jordan, Isaac Jordan, Felipe Martinez, Ryan Taylor, Kyle Lawson, Rocky Jordan
2 time SC’s - Josh Wooten, Dave Erwin, Aaron Hart, Zach Neibert, Nick Brascetta, Eli Seipel, Brent Moore
Click to expand...
9 four time SCs Winn’s IMO albeit Div 2. It’s still lines up with Ed’s IMO. Very impressive.
[/QUOTE]
From 106 to 171 all are college AA’s too except for Mitch who still has time to get one. And the only non 4 timer in those weights was a 2 time NCAA finalist
 
Divided42 said:
I’m convinced, it was Zerkle or Bair or Sarver. I frankly didn’t do the deep dive research on Zerkle or Bair as they were before my time.
Click to expand...

All 3 were state champions but I gave Zerkle an edge due to his 2nd place finish to Jeff Knupp (6-1-1-1) and being a 2 time NCAA qualifier at Lock Haven.
 
Marysville line up using current wt classes
This was really hard trying to figure out which guys to insert where, which year to use for wt class? ex: Taleb Rahmani started was 4th at 106 but a champ at 152. Knowing all of the guys on this list it was really hard to make some of these picks.

106-
113- Hayden Lee State Champ Class of 2014
120- Dallas Hucle (4,4,SQ) Class of 2003
126- Jake McCombs (2,3,8 SQ) Class of 2010
132- Josh Palivoda (Champ,5,8,SQ) Class of 2007
138- Noah Forrider (Champ,4,6,8) Class of 2013
145- Jake Marsh (2,SQ,6,SQ)
152- Taleb Rahmani (Champ, 4,7,4) Class of 2015
160- Caleb Marsh (3,6,4,SQ) Class of 2010
170- Matt Laffollette (SQ,8,SQ)
182- Kip MIchael (5, SQ,SQ) Class of 1985
195- Ben Rings (Champ, Runner-up) Class of 2000
220- Austin Pfarr (Champ,5) Class of 2014
285- Tyler Connolly (inj,5, SQ) Class of 2019

Guys I can't believe aren't in the line-up
4x Qualifier 3X Placer Walker Heard
State Champ Luke Wimmers
4x Qualifier 2x Placer David Sparks
3x Qualifier 3x Placer Nate Weeks
State Runner-up Alex Sepeda
 
FAIRVIEW PARK FAIRVIEW HIGH SCHOOL All-Time Squad
(With a little flexibility in weight classes)
106: Stephen Mendicino, 3rd State 2x
113: Brian Legarth, 2-time State Runner-up
120: Ron Cantini, 2x SP, NCAA qualifier at Michigan State
126: David Byrne, 2nd State
132: Drew Pariano, 3x State Champion, 3x NCAA Qualifier at Northwestern
138: Pat Hoy, State Champion and two-time Finalist
145: Anthony Pariano, 2-time State Champion, 4x SP, All-American at Northwestern
152: Pat Knaze, 2nd State, 3x SP
160: Jay Mendicino, 2nd State, 2x SP
170: John Sivori, State Champion
182: Brad Kohler, State Champion
195: Ron Varga, State Champion and two-time Finalist, NJCAA runner-up at CCC-West and 3-time NCAA qualifier at Cleveland State
220: Paul Readinger, 5th State
285: Eric Hehl (Neily), State Champion and two-time Finalist, NCAA Qualifier at Ohio State
Other accomplished performers:
Phil Kennedy, 2nd State;; Rich Turgeon, 3rd State; John Kohler 4th State; Jim Burger, 4th State; Brandon Payne, 5th State, William Edwards, 5th State, Jason DeFranco, 5th State, Corey Carlo, 2x SP.
 
monarchpride said:
Marysville line up using current wt classes
This was really hard trying to figure out which guys to insert where, which year to use for wt class? ex: Taleb Rahmani started was 4th at 106 but a champ at 152. Knowing all of the guys on this list it was really hard to make some of these picks.

106-
113- Hayden Lee State Champ Class of 2014
120- Dallas Hucle (4,4,SQ) Class of 2003
126- Jake McCombs (2,3,8 SQ) Class of 2010
132- Josh Palivoda (Champ,5,8,SQ) Class of 2007
138- Noah Forrider (Champ,4,6,8) Class of 2013
145- Jake Marsh (2,SQ,6,SQ)
152- Taleb Rahmani (Champ, 4,7,4) Class of 2015
160- Caleb Marsh (3,6,4,SQ) Class of 2010
170- Matt Laffollette (SQ,8,SQ)
182- Kip MIchael (5, SQ,SQ) Class of 1985
195- Ben Rings (Champ, Runner-up) Class of 2000
220- Austin Pfarr (Champ,5) Class of 2014
285- Tyler Connolly (inj,5, SQ) Class of 2019

Guys I can't believe aren't in the line-up
4x Qualifier 3X Placer Walker Heard
State Champ Luke Wimmers
4x Qualifier 2x Placer David Sparks
3x Qualifier 3x Placer Nate Weeks
State Runner-up Alex Sepeda
Click to expand...

Great Marysville list. My guys Derek Sharp and Tyler Bates should be at least honorable mention.
 
pcbuck said:
Walsh Jesuit:
106 Don Horning: 2X SC, 2X NCAA AA
113 Jimmy Johnson 2X SC
120 Adam Plouse: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
126 Johnni Dijulius: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup
132 Sonny Marchette: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr Champ
138 Nate Skonieczny: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup
145 Clint Musser: 3X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Cadet & Jr Runnerup, NCAA Runnerup
152 Joe Heskett: 3X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, NCAA Champ, 2X NCAA Runnerup
160 David Rella: 2X SC, 1X Runnerup, Fargo Jr 3rd x 2
170 Markus Mollica: 2X SC, Fargo Jr Champ, 2X NCAA Champ, 4X NCAA All America
182 Mike Pucillo: 1X SC, 2X Runnerup, NCAA Champ, NCAA Runnerup
195 Jeff Knupp: 3X SC, Fargo Cadet Champ
220 Viktor Sveda: 1X SC, Fargo Jr Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
HVY ?? Matt Tyla: Ironman placer

Honorable mention:
Rich Robusto: 2X SC
Josh Zupancic: 1X SC, 3X State Runnerup, 2X NCAA All America
Click to expand...

So good a guy like Alex Mackall doesn't even get mentioned. SC 3X finalist
 
falcons53 said:
So good a guy like Alex Mackall doesn't even get mentioned. SC 3X finalist
Click to expand...

You're right. I added him to the list. I remembered the championship but forgot about the 2nd finalist honor.
I don't think I'd put him ahead of Plouse or Dijulius though.
 
Solon

106: Randy Minadeo 1x SC, 3rd
113: Brandon Thompson 3x SC
120: Garrett Henry 1x SC, 5th
126: Billy Lally 1x SC, 4th
132: Kevin Hardy 3x SC, 3rd, Fargo 7th, NHSCA 8th, NAIA Champ, 3rd, Q
138: Vinny DiGiovanni 1x SC, 2nd, Q, NHSCA 3rd
145: Gregg Genovese 2x SC
152: Anthony Collica 3x SC, Q, 2x Fargo Champ, Fargo 4th, NCAA 4th, 4x Q, 4x Big 12 Champ
160: Kevin Welsh 1X SC, NHSCA Champ, NCAA 6th, 3x Q (bumped from 152)
170: Kevin Boross 1x SC, 2nd, Q, NHSCA 7th, 3x NCAA Q, 1x ACC Champ (bumped up from 160)
182: Bob Genovese 1x SC, 2nd, 5th (bumped up from 175)
195: Matt Camino 5th, Q
220: Zach Stolarsky 7th, Q
285: Dennis Meggysey 1x SC, 3rd

2nd Team
106: Jordan Brown 2nd, 4th, Q, World Maccabi Games Silver and Bronze
113: Todd Boerner 3rd, 5th, 6th, Q
120: Jake Canitano 2nd, 3rd, 5th
126: Lenny Schork 2x 2nd, Q, NHSCA 4th
132: Vince Gioella 2x 6th
138: Jim Barto 1x SC, Q
145: Deonte Penn 2nd, NHSCA 6th, 2x NCAA All-American 4th, 7th
152: Myron Mahone 2nd, 3rd, NJCAA Champ
160: David Mahone 6th, Q
170: Tom Kruse 1x SC, 2x NCAA Q (dropped from 175)
182: Leo Caito 3rd, 5th (bumped up from 175)
195: Todd Krajnak 2x Q (dropped from 215)
220: Michael Barnett Q
285: Nate Hoff 5th
 
Last edited:
LouieIacoboni said:
Nordonia
106 D. Tussell
113 Randy Jenkins
120 Ray Jenkins
126 L. Vance
132 G. Iacoboni
138 Jim Andrassey
145 L. Iacoboni
152 Joe Andrassey
160 R. Lange
170 C. Grether
182 S. Perrine
195 A. Perrine
220 J. Tanner
hvy Wojo
had a handful of 220's to choose from between Tanner Wojo and Trusnick.
so many other guys you could throw in there as well. Artino, Billow, Mullins, Paulas and so on....
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top