1917: 5.5/8
I found myself a bit disappointed with this movie. It's visually stunning to be sure, and the continuous shot draws you in. After awhile though you forget you're watching a continuous shot though, and you're just left with writing and plot. That's where this movie lost me. The main character should have (well WOULD have) died no less than four times in this movie based on the events that took place. Somehow though, he comes out relatively unscathed. Even when they make you think he was shot, apparently it just grazed his ear and he fell down the steps and was knocked unconscious. Near the end, he walks into a group of soldiers, his own in fairness, but not a single soldier was on lookout. He just walks up and sits next to them up against a tree. I mean wtf? the biggest issue with this movie is that time after time it sacrifices believe-ability for a great visual shot. When in truth, the main character is an idiot and never would have completed his mission. Yet too much Mendes chooses the great shot over a believable scene. Lastly, German soldiers make Storekeepers look like sharp shooters.
The Gentlemen: 7.5/8
As others have said, hard to find faults with this movie. I'm not sure I can find one other than to say it didn't feel perfect, if that makes sense. I don't know that I had expectations going into this movie, but at the same time it didn't go the way I would have expected. As weird as that sounds. Great acting all around and a solid story.