NFL All-Time Team

GoArrowsGo

GoArrowsGo

Well-known member
Just for a little bit of fun to stir up some conversation since the NFL is pretty quiet until the draft. Who would you consider to be the best players for each position for the Bengals to create an "All-Time" team. Here's my list...discuss and debate.

QB - Ken Anderson (Boomer and Palmer as backups)
Running Backs - James Brooks and Corey Dillon
Receivers - Tim McGee, A.J Green, Chad Johnson, Isaac Curtis
Offensive Tackles - Anthony Munoz, Willie Anderson
Center - Bob Johnson
Offensive Guards - Bruce Kozerski, Max Montoya
Tight Ends - Bob Trumpy, Tyler Eifert

Defensive Line - Carlos Dunlap, Eddie Edwards, Geno Atkins, Mike Reid
Linebackers - Vontaze Burfict, James Francis, Takeo Spikes
Defensive Backs - Reggie Nelson, David Fulcher, Ken Riley, Leon Hall

Kicker - Jim Breech
Punter - Kevin Huber

What do you guys think? Feel free to post your All Time team if you are a fan of another team.
 
 
QB Greg Cook [Ken Anderson]
RB James Brooks, Corey Dillon [Pete Johnson, Paul Robinson]
WR Isaac Curtis, AJ Green [Chad Johnson, Carl Pickens]
TE Bob Trumpy, Rodney Holman [Dan Ross, Tony McGee]
OT Anthony Munoz, Andrew Whitworth [Willie Anderson, Joe Walter]
OG Bruce Kozerski, Max Montoya [Dave Lapham, Pat Matson]
C Bob Johnson [Blair Bush]
DE Coy Bacon, Eddie Edwards [Carlos Dunlap, Ross Browner]
DT Tim Kumrie, Geno Atkins [Mike Reid, Dan Wilkinson]
OLB Reggie Williams, James Francis [Vontase Burfict, Brian Simmons]
ILB Bill Bergey [Jim LeClair, Takeo Spikes]
CB Ken Riley, Leon Hall [Louis Breeden, Lamar Parrish]
S Tommy Cassanova, David Fulcher [Reggie Nelson, Rickey Dixon]

K Horst Muhlmann [Jim Breech]
P Kevin Huber [Pat McInally]
 
Termite2 said:
QB Greg Cook [Ken Anderson]
RB James Brooks, Corey Dillon [Pete Johnson, Paul Robinson]
WR Isaac Curtis, AJ Green [Chad Johnson, Carl Pickens]
TE Bob Trumpy, Rodney Holman [Dan Ross, Tony McGee]
OT Anthony Munoz, Andrew Whitworth [Willie Anderson, Joe Walter]
OG Bruce Kozerski, Max Montoya [Dave Lapham, Pat Matson]
C Bob Johnson [Blair Bush]
DE Coy Bacon, Eddie Edwards [Carlos Dunlap, Ross Browner]
DT Tim Kumrie, Geno Atkins [Mike Reid, Dan Wilkinson]
OLB Reggie Williams, James Francis [Vontase Burfict, Brian Simmons]
ILB Bill Bergey [Jim LeClair, Takeo Spikes]
CB Ken Riley, Leon Hall [Louis Breeden, Lamar Parrish]
S Tommy Cassanova, David Fulcher [Reggie Nelson, Rickey Dixon]

K Horst Muhlmann [Jim Breech]
P Kevin Huber [Pat McInally]
Click to expand...

I assume with Greg Cook you’re basing that off of what he could have been? He didn’t get to play too long before the arm injury?

Never heard of Muhlmann....I’ll have to look him up!
 
For fun I will put the Browns All-Time Team (IMO)

QB - Otto Graham (Bernie Kosar)
RB - Jim Brown, Leroy Kelly (Marion Motley, Greg or Mike Pruitt)
WR - Dante Lavelli, Paul Warfield (Gary Collins, Reggie Rucker)
TE - Ozzie Newsome (Milt Moran)
OT - Joe Thomas, Lou Groza (Doug Dieken)
OG - Joe DeLamilleure(SP), Gene Hickerson (Dick Schafrath)
C- Tom DeLeone (Alex Mack)
DL- Bob Golic, Jerry Sherk, Michael Dean Perry, Lyle Alzado
OLB - Clay Mathews, Jamir Miller,
ILB - Dick Ambrose, Mike Johnson
CB - Frank Minnifield, Hanford Dixon (Joe Haden)
S - Thom Darden, Eric Turner (Felix Wright)

K - Phil Dawson (Lou Groza)
P - Chris Gardocki (Steve Cox)
KR - Josh Cribbs (Terry McCafe)
Coaches - Paul Brown (Marty Schottenheimer)
 
joesports said:
For fun I will put the Browns All-Time Team (IMO)

QB - Otto Graham (Bernie Kosar)
RB - Jim Brown, Leroy Kelly (Marion Motley, Greg or Mike Pruitt)
WR - Dante Lavelli, Paul Warfield (Gary Collins, Reggie Rucker)
TE - Ozzie Newsome (Milt Moran)
OT - Joe Thomas, Lou Groza (Doug Dieken)
OG - Joe DeLamilleure(SP), Gene Hickerson (Dick Schafrath)
C- Tom DeLeone (Alex Mack)
DL- Bob Golic, Jerry Sherk, Michael Dean Perry, Lyle Alzado
OLB - Clay Mathews, Jamir Miller,
ILB - Dick Ambrose, Mike Johnson
CB - Frank Minnifield, Hanford Dixon (Joe Haden)
S - Thom Darden, Eric Turner (Felix Wright)

K - Phil Dawson (Lou Groza)
P - Chris Gardocki (Steve Cox)
KR - Josh Cribbs (Terry McCafe)
Coaches - Paul Brown (Marty Schottenheimer)
Click to expand...


Some additions, all Pro Football Hall of Famers:

DE- Len Ford
DT- Bill Willis
C- Frank Gatski
RB- Bobby Mitchell

Others:
LB- Chip Banks
CB- Hanford Dixon
QB- Milt Plum
Coach- Blanton Collier
 
Don't want to hijack the thread, but since you went there, here's my all-time Browns team, in alphabetical order:

Offense:

QB: Otto Graham, Bernie Kosar
RB: Jim Brown, Leroy Kelly, Marion Motley, Greg Pruitt
WR: Dante Lavelli, Webster Slaughter, Mac Speedie, Paul Warfield
TE: Milt Morin, Ozzie Newsome
OT: Lou Groza, Dick Schfrath, Joe Thomas
C: Frank Gatski, Alex Mack
OG: Gene Hickerson, Mike McCormack, Jim Ray Smith
KR: Josh Cribbs, Eric Metcalf
PK: Phil Dawson

Defense:

DE: Len Ford, Bill Glass, Bill Willis
NG: Michael Dean Perry
DT: Bob Gain, Walter Johnson, Jerry Sherk
LB: Galen Fiss, Jim Houston, D'Qwell Jackson, Clay Matthews
S: Thom Darden, Don Colo
CB: Hanford Dixon, Warren Lahr, Frank Minniefield, Clarence Scott
P: Don Cockroft

Head Coach: Who else...Paul Brown.
 
OK Bengals & Browns fans ... If there was an all-time Ohio team who would you pick?

I will start ... Paul Brown as coach!
 
Pittsburgh Steelers

QB: Ben Rothliesberger, Terry Bradshaw
RB:Franco Harris
RB:Jerome Bettis
WR:John Stallworth, Hines Ward
WR: Antonio Brown, Lynn Swann
TE: Heath Miller, Elbie Nickel
T: Jon Kolb, Larry Brown
T: Tunch Ilkon
G: Alan Faneca, John Nisby
G: Dermonti Dawson (played G 1 yr moved to Center)
C: Mike Webster

DE: LC Greenwood
DE: Aaron Smith
DT: Joe Greene
DT: Ernie Stautner, Casey Hampton
LB: Jack Ham
LB: Greg Lloyd , Joey Porter
LB: Jack Lambert
DB: Rod Woodson
DB: Mel Blount
S: Troy Polamalu, Jack Butler
S: Donnie Shell

K: Gary Anderson
P: Bobby Walden

Coach: Chuck Noll
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top