It would be awfully difficult, if not impossible, to top the 1958 Class AA state tournament for sheer thrills and excitement. East Tech took an early lead and then held on to defeat Zanesville, 53-47, in one semi-final game. In the other, Columbus North shocked the basketball world by upsetting two-time defending state champion Middletown, 63-62, handing the Middies their first, and only, loss in three seasons.
Seldom have two teams been so evenly matched in a tournament final as were East Tech and Columbus North in 1958. And if the folks at St. John Arena thought that they had seen a great game when North upset Middletown, then they were in for an even greater treat the next day. Tech and North fought back and forth during the entire game. With North leading 48-46 and just six seconds left on the game clock, East Tech’s Jim Stone hit on a 35-footer to tie the score and send the game into overtime.
Neither team was able to score in the first overtime period. By the rules of the day, the second OT would be sudden death – first team to score wins. North gained first possession of the ball in the second OT, but lost it on a bad pass. East Tech then worked the ball down the court. Ed Ferguson passed the ball to Gerald Warren. Warren drove toward the basket, pulled up and, with just 34 seconds gone in the second overtime, canned a jump shot in the paint it give East Tech – and Cleveland – its first state basketball title, 50-48. That year was the last time that the sudden-death format was used.