The CBC is not the MAC. No one is. You're going to have to get over that arrogance to be able to enjoy your "new conference."
But it's also not nearly as bad as you make it sound. I'm assuming you're talking "football" specifically. Last year was a bad year, I agree. But since 2009 (last 10 years) the CBC's top playoff performers:
2018: Northwestern - Regional Quarterfinals - Lost to State Champion Wyoming
2017: Bellefontaine - Regional Semifinals - Lost to State Runner-Up Tri-Valley in OT
2016: Indian Lake - Regional Semifinals - Lost to Ottawa-Glandorff by 5, who lost to State Champion Hartley by 3
2015: Kenton Ridge - Regional Semifinals - Lost to Bellevue by 7, who lost to State Champion Hartley by 8
2014: Tippecanoe - Regional Semifinals - Lost to Wapakoneta
2013: Tippecanoe - Regional Finals- Lost to State Runner-Up Trotwood-Madison
2012: Shawnee - Regional Semifinals - Lost to Athens by 1 after beating state power Archbishop Alter on the road by 8
2011: Shawnee - State Championship - Lost to Cardinal Mooney 21-14
2010: Shawnee - Regional Semifinals - Lost to Eaton
2009: Shawnee - Regional Finals - Lost to state runner-up Wyoming by 7
***What I've learned after doing this research (hahaha). I thought Tippecanoe dominated the CBC while they were in it. Playoff performance suggests otherwise. I also didn't realize that Urbana has been this down, for this long. That's a shame.
The CBC lost a pretty good school (as far as from a competitive standpoint) in Tippecanoe. They've done a nice job salvaging the conference and bringing in schools like Jonathan Alder, London and North Union. IMO, that made the conference stronger.