You mean like the South Dakota State that Minnesota opened with?
Rich when other conferences knock the SEC for scheduling games... I'd say in most other conferences, the best teams have 5-6 conference cupcake games, along with their 3-4 non-conf cupcake games.In two weeks, Ohio State will be playing Penn State and Alabama will be playing a FCS school. Alabama does not deserve to be included in the playoff conversation.
Two of the best, for sure. But Ohio State and Clemson can make the same claim. I would put LSU at #1 this week, with the Buckeyes #2, Clemson #3 and Alabama #4. How the SEC plays out will determine Bama's fate. Who knows? We may find out in the coming weeks that LSU and Bama's D's stink, as they get lit up by someone. Not sure how that can happen, though, with Georgia and Auburn being offensively challenged. I know it would be bad for Bama if UGA runs the table, and wins the SEC over LSU. If Minnesota can finish out unbeaten, they will have earned their shot against the Buckeyes...assuming OSU can win out. Oklahoma gets a chance for a win over unbeaten Baylor....but the Bears could be unbeaten in the end. Utah and Oregon get a shot at each other. The only sure thing I see is Clemson running the table. The rest is uncertain.I'm so happy Minnesota beat Penn State Saturday. It just makes the committee look silly. There is no way anyone could honestly put Penn State in the top 4 before Saturday based on what they've done this year. What a mess they have now? So do you put Minnesota in the 4 spot?
How about that LSU/ Bama game Saturday??? Can you tell me they aren't the best two teams in the country?? LSU has the best resume in the country, and it's not even close folks. Now, things can and will change the next few weeks, but at this point, if you're on the committee and you look at everything that's happened, LSU has to be #1.
Bama is in a tough spot. They really don't have much left. They can't get in the SEC finals, unless really stubbs their toe, very unlikely. Bama has to roll it up the rest of the year, including an impressive win at Auburn to have ANY shot of getting in, and it still may not be good enough. Ohio State will roll through the rest of their schedule. I see them winning big over Penn State and Michigan both. Locks for the playoffs now are the Buckeyes and Clemson.Two of the best, for sure. But Ohio State and Clemson can make the same claim. I would put LSU at #1 this week, with the Buckeyes #2, Clemson #3 and Alabama #4. How the SEC plays out will determine Bama's fate. Who knows? We may find out in the coming weeks that LSU and Bama's D's stink, as they get lit up by someone. Not sure how that can happen, though, with Georgia and Auburn being offensively challenged. I know it would be bad for Bama if UGA runs the table, and wins the SEC over LSU. If Minnesota can finish out unbeaten, they will have earned their shot against the Buckeyes...assuming OSU can win out. Oklahoma gets a chance for a win over unbeaten Baylor....but the Bears could be unbeaten in the end. Utah and Oregon get a shot at each other. The only sure thing I see is Clemson running the table. The rest is uncertain.
I'm so happy Minnesota beat Penn State Saturday. It just makes the committee look silly. There is no way anyone could honestly put Penn State in the top 4 before Saturday based on what they've done this year. What a mess they have now? So do you put Minnesota in the 4 spot?
How about that LSU/ Bama game Saturday??? Can you tell me they aren't the best two teams in the country?? LSU has the best resume in the country, and it's not even close folks. Now, things can and will change the next few weeks, but at this point, if you're on the committee and you look at everything that's happened, LSU has to be #1.
That's irrelevant, given you had an undefeated Baylor ranked 11.Penn State is undfeated,
Wisconsin?? Can't forgive that loss to Illinois. Illinois is bad. They are worse than Purdue last year and Iowa the year before for the Buckeyes.
Yes, if you want to include Michigan fine.
This issue is that with the conferences the way they are, with the numbers of teams you're always going to have 3-4 teams from the power conferences. They don't play enough of each other. One way I evaluate is to put teams in other conferences. For instance. Wisconsin would probably lose 4-5 games in the SEC. In the big ten, especially the west division, they are always in contention. I'd put Penn State in there as well. And even Ohio State, most years I'd say they could lose 3-4 conference games in the SEC. There are just too many layups in the big ten.
I'm so happy Minnesota beat Penn State Saturday. It just makes the committee look silly.
1. LSU
2. Ohio State
3. Clemson
4. Alabama
You can flip 3 and 4. Bama has the best 1 loss resume, but really has little else to up their ante.
If LSU and Ohio State win out, LSU has to be the #1 seed. Athough it really does not matter, they should be #1 and #2 when the dust settles, regardless.
It will be very interesting to see where Minnesota ends up tonight.
So Penn State loses and doesn't move?? Or are you just trying to make the Buckeyes resume as good as possible??1. LSU
2. Ohio State
3. Clemson
4. Penn State
5. Georgia
6. Alabama
The CFP committee bias toward the SEC is sickening. UGA 4th ? An UGA team that lost to South Carolina, barely beat ND, a team Mich. destroyed. Alabama 5th? Other than Texas A & M has Alabama def. another team with a winning record. If OSU were to lose to PSU and PSU wins the BIG title are we going to have 3 SEC schools in the play offs ? In a way I would like to see that happen so The CFP's hypocrisy is completely exposed and the whole thing gets blown up.
Let's say it's Oregon. Their best win would be over Utah. Oregon would be 12-1 with a loss to Auburn. Bama would be 11-1 with a win over Auburn, which would be their best win. They would have played #1 LSU within 5 points with an injured QB. Does anyone really believe the committee will leave out Bama in that scenario? Especially knowing the public would salivate over a rematch, with OSU vs Clemson being a very attractive lead-in. It would be their best ratings ever.It doesn't really matter does it? They'll lose to LSU and they'll be out. Alabama 5th means they're out as long as Oregon-Utah remain 1 loss when they meet in the Pac12 championship. Or unless chaos happens.
Let's say it's Oregon. Their best win would be over Utah. Oregon would be 12-1 with a loss to Auburn. Bama would be 11-1 with a win over Auburn, which would be their best win. They would have played #1 LSU within 5 points with an injured QB. Does anyone really believe the committee will leave out Bama in that scenario? Especially knowing the public would salivate over a rematch, with OSU vs Clemson being a very attractive lead-in. It would be their best ratings ever.
I disagree. I think it would get huge national ratings. Heck, as annoying as I sometimes find the SEC...I would love to see a rematch of those two in a first round playoff game.Since I predicted the winner of Oregon-Utah, assuming they are both still 1 loss teams when they meet and LSU, OSU and Clemson run the table, yes I really believe the committee will leave out Bama.
There was a rather large outcry in 2011 when there was a rematch. Outside of Tuscaloosa, I'm not sure too many are salivating for a rematch. I don't think LSU wants anything to do with a rematch with Saban.
11 conference champs and 5 at-large. Seeds based on computer rankings. The human element should be completely done away with. It shouldn't be this hard.Just expand to 16 team playoff already. Then we are arguing about teams without a shot at winning being left out and the tournament is actually legit.