Wayne High School was established in 1956. This is where I found the first ever football score between Centerville and Wayne. I also didn't see any score with Centerville playing Titus. If you have any other info with scores, this would be great!
Wayne existed in 56 but Huber Heights Wayne was not established until 1981. Prior to 56 the high school was Titus. It still exists today and one of your heroes Mr. Staley attended that school.