Where did I say replacing a 3 for 15 kicker is the most glaring need for next year? Did I say that? No, I didnt. I pointed out how if that 3 for 15 kicker had the kind of year he had LAST year it would have changed Moe's playoff results... people like you who misread or simply don't understand what you read crack me up.
Second... you agree that neither qb upcoming is McVittie caliber... I don't need to see them play that much at all to see that fact. I don't care if they were playing the best team south of Cleveland. In fact, the best team south of Cleveland only won by 2... missed field goals and McVittie would have changed that outcome dramatically. Exactly as I said and exactly as another poster pointed out how important a solid kicking game is.
Third... you state Hensley was "solid"... that solid player lead the D line in tackles over even over Meyer... who was named GCL something-or-other. The other DT... who? The other end? Who? Exactly. I've seen Hawkins at practice. Better at that position? No. Not even close. Meiser I know personally. Great kid. But Hawkins and Meiser are simply no where near the athletes Hensley and Meyer are. Meyer and Hensley made up the D line. Unless something changes, I doubt you'll be "fine" at that position.
Fourth... you totally ignored my remarks about the coaching. IMO... vanilla at best when it came to offense. McVittie was a playmaker, and it showed. Without him, we lose to Elder. That's pretty obvious. And Moeller has its first losing season. When looking at the head coach, years from start to finish, the rise in wins coincides with hires and the decline coincides with departures. Go ahead. Take an honest look at that aspect.
Everybody wants to think their kids class is going to be better than the class above. I know we did. And that's fine. No shame in that. But given the coaching this year, the lack of talent in the secondaries, the lack of rising stars in linebackers (said yourself you couldn't name any replacements for Griega, Raga), the lack of a D1 qb, and the step down in a couple other areas I'd say Moe needs to take a hard look at what's happening. I love Moe football. But to tie for the worse record ever and then say the next class is better is ridiculous. If they were... they would have played over every player you mentioned. The fact is, they werent.
BTW, "road grater lineman" is grossly incorrect. "GRATER" is an ice cream company I think. A road GRADER is a machine that sets grade to a road or building pad. I know. I run one.