I'm a realtor so the best analogy that I can think of is in housing market terms. The Vandalia job is a "fixer upper". Good solid house that really needs some structural work and TLC but sits right in the perfect location. Will take a lot of work but can be a million dollar house for a steal. What I mean is that Vandalia's facilities for football and training and conditioning is great. The support of the administration and AD is great.
The downside is the current talent pool. It's not great. There are some great athletes in the halls but the majority of them are not playing football. (There are some great athletes on the football team; Point is there are many great athletes NOT on the football team) That's a big difference from what is happening at Tipp, Troy, Piqua, Sidney, etc. That needs to change. This new coach can't magically bring a culture to fix everything. The kids in the halls, weight room, locker room have to decide what kind of culture they want. Cultivate, Protect and Pass It On. The new coach can bring enthusiasm and create an environment for that to blossom but it starts, lives and dies with the players.
When Vandalia was competing for state all those years ago the best athletes were playing football, basketball and baseball. The result? Vandalia was killing it in football, basketball and baseball. So the difference then was just darn good athletes in general that we probably lack today but also kids playing multiple sports. Vandalia has great wrestlers and basketball players but I can think of very few that play football. Maybe a few baseball kids playing football but again not many.
I'm under no illusion that Vandalia is going to rise to the level of those days when they were winning 2, 3, 4 playoff games a year but they should be competitive each season. No reason why they can't be a consistent 6-4/7-3 and looking for that 8 seed each year with a 8-2 year sprinkled in from time to time. It will take a coach that can get the kids excited again so charisma would really go along way with this hire. Would also like to see a coach get in here and stick with it. Consistency would really help the program. Bush was the last coach to last more than 3 years and in looking back was pretty consistent in that 6-4 area I mentioned earlier. Arguably against tougher competition than the MVL. (A solid point that ButlerParent has made in the past)