It's December and this isn't looking so crazy now. Bills have a chance to pull even with the Pats on Saturday. Allen is still a question mark. Very inconsistent. Still though the defense is solid and they are a fun team to watch. Depending on who they match up with in the postseason they could even pull out a win in wild card weekend.
I think Allen's inconsistency is overstated. IMO it's no more then one would expect from most 2nd year QB's. As one of the rawest high QB draft picks in recent memory Allen was a real project. That he is ahead of schedule seems pretty clear to me.
One thing that hurts Allen is his perception among the "expert" NFL guys. Coming out of Wyoming 90% of these folks, who never actually played QB, stated that Allen would be a bust on the order of Ryan Leaf. These guys, mostly wedded to their ridiculous analytics (football is chaotic with a minimum sample size so not suited IMO to sophisticated statistical analysis) even went back to Allen's HS career to justify their statements that he could NEVER be accurate.
But the eye test, which I still think is the best metric for a QB, says that Allen is almost there. He still needs to improve aspects of his game and like Brett Farve, whose game I think Allen's most closely resembles, he'll make the boneheaded throw.
Now before folks jump in and quote me the conventional stats showing Allen in the bottom 1/3 of QB's here's some stats that I think reinforce the eye test and are actually better measures of a QB:
* Total TD's, both passing & rushing. In the new era of Lamar Jackson rushing TD's will be an important QB metric. So if you take total TD's (passing + rushing) and compare that number to total turnovers (INT's + LOST fumbles) you get a great read on how good a QB is. Allen is currently 6th in the NFL with 27 TD's. And while his detractors claim Allen is a turnover machine the facts say otherwise as he has a total of only 13 TO's. So his # is 27/13 which is above a 2 ratio and quite good.
* Other stats that show Allen in a better light are his 4th quarter QB rating. He is currently #3 in the NFL. And it's not because he's piling up garbage stats because the Bills have had very closely contested 4th quarters.
* Another impressive Allen stat is that in the Red Zone he's the 3rd rated QB and is tied for 3rd in total red zone TD's. This is key for a team like Buffalo that has an elite D but only an average O.
* Finally, Allen is clutch as he's tied with Russel Wilson for the lead in leading game winning 4th quarter drives with 5. Last year he had 3 giving him a total of 8 game winning drives in 25 NFL starts.
I think it's interesting to note that if you were judging the 2018 QB class TODAY Jackson is #1 and Allen is #2. But on draft day 2018 those 2 were considered the least likely to succeed. The NFL is changing at the QB position and this time I think it's for real and will be long lasting.